Martínez-Juárez Iris E, Funes Bianca, Moreno-Castellanos Julio C, Bribiesca-Contreras Elisa, Martínez-Bustos Verónica, Zertuche-Ortuño Lizeth, Hernández-Vanegas Laura E, Ronquillo Lizbeth Hernandez, Rizvi Syed, Adam Wu, Tellez-Zenteno Jose F
Epilepsy Clinic: National Institute of Neurology and Neurosurgery Mexico City Mexico.
Saskatchewan Epilepsy Program Division of Neurology Department of Medicine University of Saskatchewan Saskatoon Saskatchewan Canada.
Epilepsia Open. 2017 Oct 19;2(4):453-458. doi: 10.1002/epi4.12082. eCollection 2017 Dec.
To provide a comprehensive transnational overview of wait times for epilepsy surgery in Canada and Mexico.
We reviewed all cases referred for epilepsy surgery between 2007 and 2015 at the Saskatchewan Epilepsy Program Royal University Hospital (SEP) (n = 70; Saskatoon, Canada) and the National Institute of Neurology and Neurosurgery (NINN) (n = 76; Mexico City, Mexico) and compared wait times, calculated as the time from diagnosis of epilepsy on assessment at an epilepsy center to epilepsy surgery.
Mean wait times were similar across centers. Mean patient age was 37.4 ± 9 years (NINN) and 36.7 ± 13.2 years (SEP). The mean time from epilepsy diagnosis to referral was 18.9 (NINN) and 16.9 years (SEP), p = 0.30; first consult with the epileptologist, 19.7 (NINN) and 17.4 years (p = 0.23); neuropsychology consult, 21.4 (NINN) and 17.9 years (SEP); video electroencephalogram (video-EEG) telemetry, 21.1 (NINN) and 18.6 months (SEP); initial neurosurgical consult, 21.9 (NINN) and 19.1 years (SEP) (p = 0.35); and epilepsy surgery, 19.7 (NINN) and 19.6 years (SEP) (p = 0.29).
This is the first study to compare wait times between Canada and Mexico. Despite disparity in their health delivery systems and financial resources, surgical wait times appeared to be protracted in both nations, confirming that delayed treatment is a universal problem that requires collaborative scrutiny.
全面跨国概述加拿大和墨西哥癫痫手术的等待时间。
我们回顾了2007年至2015年间在萨斯喀彻温省癫痫项目皇家大学医院(SEP)(n = 70;加拿大萨斯卡通)和国家神经病学和神经外科研究所(NINN)(n = 76;墨西哥城,墨西哥)转诊进行癫痫手术的所有病例,并比较了等待时间,等待时间计算为从癫痫中心评估诊断癫痫到癫痫手术的时间。
各中心的平均等待时间相似。患者平均年龄为37.4±9岁(NINN)和36.7±13.2岁(SEP)。从癫痫诊断到转诊的平均时间为18.9年(NINN)和16.9年(SEP),p = 0.30;首次咨询癫痫专家,19.7年(NINN)和17.4年(p = 0.23);神经心理学咨询,21.4年(NINN)和17.9年(SEP);视频脑电图(video - EEG)遥测,21.1个月(NINN)和18.6个月(SEP);首次神经外科咨询,21.9年(NINN)和19.1年(SEP)(p = 0.35);以及癫痫手术,19.7年(NINN)和19.6年(SEP)(p = 0.29)。
这是第一项比较加拿大和墨西哥等待时间的研究。尽管两国的医疗保健系统和财政资源存在差异,但两国的手术等待时间似乎都很长,这证实了延迟治疗是一个普遍问题,需要共同审视。