Dekker Marieke C J, Urasa Sarah J, Kellogg Marissa, Howlett William P
Department of Internal Medicine and Pediatrics Kilimanjaro Christian Medical Centre Moshi Tanzania.
Department of Neurology Radboud University Medical Centre Nijmegen The Netherlands.
Epilepsia Open. 2018 Jan 23;3(1):66-72. doi: 10.1002/epi4.12096. eCollection 2018 Mar.
Functional neurological disorders (FNDs) and psychogenic nonepileptic seizures (PNES) are likely as common in Sub-Saharan Africa (SSA) as in the rest of the world, but there is a dearth of literature on the epidemiology and clinical presentation of these disorders in Africa. The purpose of this paper is to describe a case series of FNDs presenting to a referral hospital in SSA. In addition, we review the existing literature on FNDs in Africa.
A hospital-based retrospective cross-sectional study was conducted to determine the prevalence, epidemiology, and clinical phenotype of FNDs and PNES in a referral hospital in Northern Tanzania over a 6-year period (2007-2013).
Of 2,040 patients presenting with neurological complaints, 44 (2.2%) were diagnosed with FNDs. Half (n = 22) had the clinical presentation of PNES. Age of presentation for FNDs and PNES peaked in the teen years 12-19 (n = 21 48%; and n = 14, 63%, respectively), and the majority were female (n = 30, 68%; and n = 14, 63%, respectively). The majority presented acutely with short-lived and self-limiting symptoms (only 2 recurrent cases). Literature review revealed multiple reports of "mass hysteria" in SSA often meeting the clinical criteria of epidemic FNDs.
FNDs and PNES occur in Africa with age and gender distribution comparable to that found elsewhere. Although the percentage of FND cases overall was relatively low (2.2%), it is likely to be an underestimate because not all cases were recorded, and cases may be appropriately managed locally before patients are referred to a hospital. PNES was the most common phenotype of FNDs reported, and the African phenotype may be short-lived and self-limiting rather than chronic and recurrent, as reported elsewhere in the world. PNES presentations may also occur in clusters, which may have cultural significance in Africa. FNDs in Africa appear to be underreported, particularly over the last 30 years.
功能性神经障碍(FNDs)和精神性非癫痫性发作(PNES)在撒哈拉以南非洲(SSA)的发病率可能与世界其他地区一样,但关于这些疾病在非洲的流行病学和临床表现的文献却很匮乏。本文旨在描述一系列在SSA一家转诊医院就诊的FNDs病例。此外,我们还回顾了非洲有关FNDs的现有文献。
进行了一项基于医院的回顾性横断面研究,以确定坦桑尼亚北部一家转诊医院在6年期间(2007 - 2013年)FNDs和PNES的患病率、流行病学及临床表型。
在2040例有神经症状的患者中,44例(2.2%)被诊断为FNDs。其中一半(n = 22)临床表现为PNES。FNDs和PNES的发病年龄在青少年时期(12 - 19岁)达到高峰(分别为n = 21,48%;n = 14,63%),且大多数为女性(分别为n = 30,68%;n = 14,63%)。大多数患者急性起病,症状短暂且自限性(仅2例复发)。文献回顾显示,SSA有多个“群体性癔症”的报道,这些报道往往符合流行性FNDs的临床标准。
FNDs和PNES在非洲的发病年龄和性别分布与其他地区相似。尽管FNDs病例的总体比例相对较低(2.2%),但这可能是低估,因为并非所有病例都有记录,而且有些病例可能在转诊到医院之前已在当地得到妥善处理。PNES是所报道的FNDs最常见的表型,非洲的表型可能是短暂且自限性的,而非如世界其他地区所报道的慢性和复发性。PNES的发作也可能呈聚集性,这在非洲可能具有文化意义。非洲的FNDs似乎报告不足,尤其是在过去30年。