Amis Samuel Martin, Osicki Tobin Henry Edgar
Department of Acute Internal Medicine, South Warwickshire Foundation Trust, Warwick, UK.
Int J Gen Med. 2018 Mar 20;11:105-112. doi: 10.2147/IJGM.S153227. eCollection 2018.
First-year doctors found that during out-of-hours shifts they were being delayed and distracted from reviewing potentially sick/deteriorating patients by a high volume of prescribing tasks. This predominately consisted of oral anticoagulation prescribing and rewrites of drug charts. We hoped that if we could reduce this burden of "inappropriate prescribing tasks", we could not only improve junior doctors' job satisfaction and opportunities for training but also give them more time for patient reviews.
Three weekends were initially audited to quantify the number of "inappropriate prescribing tasks" using data from the hospital's computerized task assigning system. On three subsequent weekends, a checklist was handed out to the ward teams on Friday mornings. This checklist was designed to encourage the day teams to check that drug charts would not need oral anticoagulation or rewriting over the weekend.
An overall reduction in "inappropriate prescribing tasks" of 46% with a specific reduction in inappropriate oral anticoagulation prescribing of 65% was observed. Inappropriate drug chart rewrites were reduced by 30%. The reduction in the mean number of pre-intervention inappropriate prescribing tasks (as a percentage of total prescribing tasks) and the post-intervention mean was 6.94% (95% confidence interval -0.54 to 14.42, -value=0.062).
Improved job satisfaction and a perceived reduced workload were noted from post-intervention qualitative surveys. While improved patient safety directly resulting from this intervention is more difficult to establish, and the observed reduction in inappropriate prescribing was only approaching statistical significance, our colleagues commented in post-intervention feedback that they felt they had more time, and felt less pressured, while attending patients. The workload of junior doctors can exert a significant effect on patient care, and simple measures can alleviate this burden. Furthermore, computerized hospital task management systems are an underutilized source of data for audit and quality improvement.
一年级医生发现,在非工作时间轮班期间,大量的处方任务使他们在检查可能生病/病情恶化的患者时受到延误和干扰。这些任务主要包括口服抗凝药处方和药物图表重写。我们希望,如果能够减轻这种“不适当处方任务”的负担,不仅可以提高初级医生的工作满意度和培训机会,还能让他们有更多时间检查患者。
最初对三个周末进行审计,利用医院计算机化任务分配系统的数据量化“不适当处方任务”的数量。在随后的三个周末,周五上午向病房团队发放一份清单。该清单旨在鼓励日间团队检查药物图表在周末是否不需要口服抗凝药或重写。
观察到“不适当处方任务”总体减少了46%,其中不适当的口服抗凝药处方具体减少了65%。不适当的药物图表重写减少了30%。干预前不适当处方任务的平均数量(占总处方任务的百分比)与干预后的平均值相比减少了6.94%(95%置信区间为-0.54至14.42,P值=0.062)。
干预后的定性调查显示工作满意度有所提高,且感觉工作量有所减轻。虽然直接因该干预措施而提高的患者安全性更难确定,且观察到的不适当处方减少仅接近统计学意义,但我们的同事在干预后的反馈中表示,他们在照看患者时感觉时间更充裕,压力更小。初级医生的工作量会对患者护理产生重大影响,而简单的措施可以减轻这种负担。此外,医院计算机化任务管理系统是审计和质量改进中未得到充分利用的数据来源。