Beehler Blake, Kochanski Ryan B, Byrne Richard, Sani Sepehr
Department of Neurosurgery, Rush University Medical College, Chicago, Illinois, USA.
Department of Neurosurgery, Rush University Medical College, Chicago, Illinois, USA.
World Neurosurg. 2018 Jun;114:e323-e328. doi: 10.1016/j.wneu.2018.02.180. Epub 2018 Mar 31.
Approximately 10%-13% of the population is left-handed (LH), and certain professions have varied representation of LH individuals. LH surgeons must overcome unique difficulties owing to the right-handed (RH) operative environment. This study assesses prevalence and impact of left-handedness on training and operative experience of neurosurgeons.
An e-mail survey was designed and sent to 5109 U.S. neurosurgeons and neurosurgical trainees. The survey was completed by 1482 responders (29.0% response rate).
Of respondents, 252 (17.0%) reported being LH. LH neurosurgeons were more likely than RH neurosurgeons to report ambidexterity in the operating room (36.5% vs. 13.3%, P < 0.001). During neurosurgical training, 23.5% of RH trainers addressed LH-specific issues compared with 44.7% of LH trainers. LH trainers were more likely to describe LH trainees as having greater technical ability (18.9%). Most trainers reported equal comfort teaching LH and RH trainees. LH trainees reported difficulties with RH surgical tools (42.7%) and a tendency to alter handedness for surgery (62.7%). The impact of these areas lessens in LH attendings (27.8% and 39.9%, respectively). Most LH neurosurgeons denied specific training for left-handedness and access to LH-specific tools, and 24.0% of LH trainees reported feeling disadvantaged owing to their handedness.
LH neurosurgeons may be overrepresented in neurosurgery, yet handedness is rarely addressed in neurosurgical training. Despite this, there is evidence of some degree of adaptation through training. There may be some benefit from recognizing differences in handedness in the operating room and attempting to give access for LH-specific mentorship during training.
大约10%-13%的人口是左利手(LH),某些职业中左利手个体的比例各不相同。由于手术环境是为右利手(RH)设计的,左利手外科医生必须克服独特的困难。本研究评估了左利手在神经外科医生培训和手术经验方面的患病率及影响。
设计了一项电子邮件调查,并发送给5109名美国神经外科医生和神经外科实习生。1482名受访者完成了调查(回复率为29.0%)。
在受访者中,252人(17.0%)报告为左利手。与右利手神经外科医生相比,左利手神经外科医生在手术室中更有可能报告双手都能灵活使用(36.5%对13.3%,P<0.001)。在神经外科培训期间,23.5%的右利手培训师涉及左利手的特定问题,而左利手培训师的这一比例为44.7%。左利手培训师更有可能将左利手实习生描述为技术能力更强(18.9%)。大多数培训师报告说,指导左利手和右利手实习生时的舒适度相同。左利手实习生报告在使用右利手手术工具时存在困难(42.7%),并且在手术时有改变用手习惯的倾向(62.7%)。在左利手主治医生中,这些方面的影响有所减轻(分别为27.8%和39.9%)。大多数左利手神经外科医生否认接受过针对左利手的特定培训,也无法获得左利手专用工具,24.0%的左利手实习生报告因自己的用手习惯而感到处于劣势。
左利手神经外科医生在神经外科领域的占比可能过高,但在神经外科培训中,用手习惯问题很少得到解决。尽管如此,有证据表明通过培训存在一定程度的适应。认识到手术室中用手习惯的差异,并在培训期间尝试提供针对左利手的指导,可能会有一些益处。