Richards Todd L, Berninger Virginia W, Yagle Kevin, Abbott Robert D, Peterson Dan
Department of Radiology, Integrated Brain Imaging Center, University of Washington, Seattle, WA, USA.
Learning Sciences and Human Development, University of Washington, Seattle, WA, USA.
Cogent Psychol. 2018;5. doi: 10.1080/23311908.2018.1424680. Epub 2018 Jan 9.
In students in grades 4 to 9 (22 males, 20 females), two reading disability groups-dyslexia ( = 20) or oral and written language learning disability (OWL LD) ( = 6)-were compared to each other and two kinds of control groups-typical readers ( = 6) or dysgraphia ( = 10) on word reading/spelling skills and fMRI imaging before and after completing 18 computerized reading lessons. Mixed ANOVAs showed significant time effects on repeated measures within participants and between groups effects on three behavioral markers of reading disabilities-word reading/spelling: All groups improved on the three behavioral measures, but those without disabilities remained higher than those with reading disabilities. On fMRI reading tasks, analyzed for graph theory derived clustering coefficients within a neural network involved in cognitive control functions, on a task the time × group interaction was significant in right medial cingulate; on a task the time × group interaction was significant in left superior frontal and left inferior frontal gyri; and on a task the time × group interaction was significant in right middle frontal gyrus. Three white matter-gray matter correlations became significant only after reading instruction: axial diffusivity in left superior frontal region with right inferior frontal gyrus during ; mean diffusivity in left superior corona radiata with left middle frontal gyrus during ; and mean diffusivity in left anterior corona radiata with right middle frontal gyrus during . Significance of results for behavioral and brain response to reading instruction (RTI) is discussed.
在4至9年级的学生中(22名男性,20名女性),将两个阅读障碍组——诵读困难组(n = 20)或口语和书面语言学习障碍组(OWL LD,n = 6)——相互比较,并与两种对照组——典型阅读者组(n = 6)或书写障碍组(n = 10),就单词阅读/拼写技能以及在完成18节计算机化阅读课程前后的功能磁共振成像(fMRI)进行比较。混合方差分析显示,在参与者内部的重复测量上存在显著的时间效应,在阅读障碍的三个行为指标——单词阅读/拼写方面存在组间效应:所有组在这三项行为测量上均有改善,但无障碍组仍高于阅读障碍组。在fMRI阅读任务中,针对参与认知控制功能的神经网络内基于图论得出的聚类系数进行分析,在一项任务中,时间×组的交互作用在右侧内侧扣带回显著;在一项任务中,时间×组的交互作用在左侧额上回和左侧额下回显著;在一项任务中,时间×组的交互作用在右侧额中回显著。三项白质-灰质相关性仅在阅读指导后变得显著:在期间,左侧额上区的轴向扩散率与右侧额下回相关;在期间,左侧放射冠上部的平均扩散率与左侧额中回相关;在期间,左侧放射冠前部的平均扩散率与右侧额中回相关。讨论了阅读指导(RTI)的行为和大脑反应结果的意义。