O'Shea Finbar, Taylor Peter C, Dickie Gavin, Yaworsky Andrew, Banderas Benjamin, Kachroo Sumesh
St. James's Hospital, Dublin, Ireland.
Nuffield Department of Orthopaedics, Rheumatology and Musculoskeletal Sciences, Botnar Research Centre, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK.
Rheumatol Ther. 2018 Jun;5(1):87-98. doi: 10.1007/s40744-018-0107-5. Epub 2018 Apr 3.
To establish clinical consensus on important and relevant quality-of-care (QoC) attributes in rheumatic disease (RD) treatment that may improve treatment outcomes and guide best practices.
Twenty-three QoC attributes were identified in a literature review. Fifteen European-based clinicians were selected based on their contributions to RD guidelines, publications, and patient care. A three-round (an interview round and two web-based rounds) modified Delphi panel was conducted to reach consensus and finalize a QoC attribute list.
In round 1 (clinician interviews), clinicians reported 52 unique QoC attributes across 14 themes, with the greatest number of attributes reported in the "treatment goals" (n = 7) and "remote monitoring" (n = 7) themes. During rounds 2 and 3, the critically important QoC attributes most frequently reported were access to care/treatment (n = 14, 93.3%), safety of treatment (round 2 n = 14, 93.3%, round 3 n = 13, 86.7%), and access to clinicians and specialists (round 2: n = 13, 86.7%, round 3: n = 14, 93.3%). The final list contained 53 QoC attributes.
The study demonstrates consensus across several themes of QoC. Quality of care is a complex, multidimensional, and fluid concept that can be improved by ensuring patients have access to care, open communication between patients and clinicians, and the use of novel strategies, such as remote monitoring. Utilization of the attribute list can potentially improve the lives of patients, provide clinicians with tools to provide greater QoC, and improve the healthcare system as a whole.
Merck & Co., Inc.
就风湿病(RD)治疗中可能改善治疗效果并指导最佳实践的重要且相关的医疗质量(QoC)属性达成临床共识。
通过文献综述确定了23个QoC属性。根据他们对RD指南、出版物和患者护理的贡献,挑选了15位欧洲临床医生。进行了三轮(一轮访谈和两轮基于网络的调查)改进的德尔菲小组讨论以达成共识并最终确定QoC属性列表。
在第1轮(临床医生访谈)中,临床医生报告了14个主题中的52个独特的QoC属性,其中“治疗目标”(n = 7)和“远程监测”(n = 7)主题中报告的属性数量最多。在第2轮和第3轮中,最常报告的至关重要的QoC属性是获得护理/治疗(第2轮n = 14,93.3%;第3轮n = 13,86.7%)、治疗安全性(第2轮n = 14,93.3%;第3轮n = 13,86.7%)以及接触临床医生和专家(第2轮:n = 13,86.7%;第3轮:n = 14,93.3%)。最终列表包含53个QoC属性。
该研究表明在QoC的几个主题上达成了共识。医疗质量是一个复杂、多维度且动态的概念,可以通过确保患者能够获得护理、患者与临床医生之间的开放沟通以及使用远程监测等新策略来加以改善。使用该属性列表可能会改善患者的生活,为临床医生提供提高QoC的工具,并改善整个医疗系统。
默克公司。