Department of Policy Analysis and Management, College of Human Ecology, Cornell University, Ithaca, New York.
Department of Sociology, College of Arts and Sciences, Cornell University, Ithaca, New York.
Epidemiol Rev. 2018 Jun 1;40(1):146-156. doi: 10.1093/epirev/mxx013.
Mass incarceration has profoundly restructured the life courses of not only marginalized adult men for whom this event is now so prevalent but also their families. We examined research published from 2000 to 2017 on the consequences of parental incarceration for child health in the United States. In addition to focusing on specific health outcomes, we also considered broader indicators of child well-being because there has been little research on the association between parental incarceration and objectively measured child health outcomes. Our findings support 4 conclusions. First, paternal incarceration is negatively associated-possibly causally so-with a range of child health and well-being indicators. Second, although some research has suggested a negative association between maternal incarceration and child health, the evidence on this front is mixed. Third, although the evidence for average effects of paternal incarceration on child health and well-being is strong, research has also suggested that some key factors moderate the association between paternal incarceration and child health and well-being. Finally, because of the unequal concentration of parental incarceration and the negative consequences this event has for children, mass incarceration has increased both intracountry inequality in child health in the United States and intercountry inequality in child health between the United States and other developed democracies. In light of these important findings, investment in data infrastructure-with emphasis on data sets that include reliable measures of parental incarceration and child health and data sets that facilitate causal inferences-is needed to understand the child health effects of parental incarceration.
大规模监禁不仅深刻地重塑了边缘化成年男性的生活轨迹,这些人现在普遍面临这种情况,也影响了他们的家庭。我们研究了 2000 年至 2017 年间发表的关于父母监禁对美国儿童健康影响的研究。除了关注特定的健康结果外,我们还考虑了更广泛的儿童福利指标,因为关于父母监禁与客观衡量的儿童健康结果之间的关联的研究很少。我们的研究结果支持以下 4 个结论。首先,父亲监禁与一系列儿童健康和福利指标呈负相关,可能具有因果关系。其次,尽管一些研究表明母亲监禁与儿童健康之间存在负相关,但这方面的证据存在分歧。第三,尽管父亲监禁对儿童健康和福利的平均影响的证据很强,但研究也表明,一些关键因素缓和了父亲监禁与儿童健康和福利之间的关联。最后,由于父母监禁的不平等集中以及这一事件对儿童的负面影响,大规模监禁不仅增加了美国国内儿童健康方面的不平等,也增加了美国与其他发达民主国家之间儿童健康方面的国家间不平等。鉴于这些重要发现,需要投资于数据基础设施,重点是包括可靠的父母监禁和儿童健康衡量标准以及有助于因果推断的数据组,以了解父母监禁对儿童健康的影响。