Academic Center for Epileptology Kempenhaeghe, Heeze, The Netherlands.
Eindhoven University of Technology, Eindhoven, the Netherlands.
Epilepsia. 2018 Jun;59 Suppl 1:30-35. doi: 10.1111/epi.14053. Epub 2018 Apr 9.
This is a critical review and comment on the use of movement detection in epileptic seizures. The detection of rhythmic movement components, such as the clonic part of tonic-clonic seizures, is essential in all seizure detection based on movement sensors. Of the many available movement sensor types, accelerometric sensors are used most often. Eleven video-electroencephalographic (EEG) and 1 field study have been carried out. The results of these clinical trials depend on the population, study design, and seizure evolution. In video-EEG monitoring units, sensitivity for tonic-clonic seizures varied from 31% to 95%, and positive predictive value from 4% to 60%. In a field trial in a residential adult population with intellectual disability, sensitivity was 14% and positive predictive value was 82%, whereas in patients admitted to an epilepsy clinic, a bed sensor had a sensitivity of 84% (no positive predictive value was given). The algorithms using the "rhythmic movement" component at the end of a tonic-clonic seizure are reliable (few false-positive alarms) but miss less typical seizure patterns that are mostly present in people with associated brain development disturbances. Other modalities (heart rate and electromyography) are needed to increase the detection performance. Advanced accelerometric techniques allow us to gain greater insight into seizure evolution patterns, possibilities for neuromodulation, and the influence of antiepileptic drugs on specific seizure components.
这是一篇关于运动检测在癫痫发作中应用的批判性回顾和评论。在基于运动传感器的所有发作检测中,都需要检测节律性运动成分,例如强直-阵挛发作的阵挛部分。在许多可用的运动传感器类型中,加速度计传感器使用最广泛。已经进行了 11 项视频-脑电图 (EEG) 和 1 项现场研究。这些临床试验的结果取决于人群、研究设计和发作演变。在视频-脑电图监测单元中,强直-阵挛发作的敏感性从 31%到 95%不等,阳性预测值从 4%到 60%不等。在智力残疾成人居住人群的现场试验中,敏感性为 14%,阳性预测值为 82%,而在癫痫诊所入院的患者中,床传感器的敏感性为 84%(未给出阳性预测值)。使用强直-阵挛发作结束时的“节律性运动”成分的算法是可靠的(假阳性警报很少),但错过了在伴有相关脑发育障碍的人群中更为常见的不太典型的发作模式。需要其他模态(心率和肌电图)来提高检测性能。先进的加速度计技术使我们能够更深入地了解发作演变模式、神经调节的可能性以及抗癫痫药物对特定发作成分的影响。