Grogger P, Sacher C, Weber S, Millesi G, Seemann R
Department of Cranio-, Maxillofacial and Oral Surgery, Medical University Vienna, 1090, Austria.
Department of Cranio-, Maxillofacial and Oral Surgery, Medical University Vienna, 1090, Austria.
Int J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2018 Oct;47(10):1322-1329. doi: 10.1016/j.ijom.2018.03.019. Epub 2018 Apr 10.
Deviations in measuring dentofacial components in a lateral X-ray represent a major hurdle in the subsequent treatment of dysgnathic patients. In a retrospective study, we investigated the most prevalent source of error in the following commonly used cephalometric measurements: the angles Sella-Nasion-Point A (SNA), Sella-Nasion-Point B (SNB) and Point A-Nasion-Point B (ANB); the Wits appraisal; the anteroposterior dysplasia indicator (APDI); and the overbite depth indicator (ODI). Preoperative lateral radiographic images of patients with dentofacial deformities were collected and the landmarks digitally traced by three independent raters. Cephalometric analysis was automatically performed based on 1116 tracings. Error analysis identified the x-coordinate of Point A as the prevalent source of error in all investigated measurements, except SNB, in which it is not incorporated. In SNB, the y-coordinate of Nasion predominated error variance. SNB showed lowest inter-rater variation. In addition, our observations confirmed previous studies showing that landmark identification variance follows characteristic error envelopes in the highest number of tracings analysed up to now. Variance orthogonal to defining planes was of relevance, while variance parallel to planes was not. Taking these findings into account, orthognathic surgeons as well as orthodontists would be able to perform cephalometry more accurately and accomplish better therapeutic results.
在侧位X线片中测量牙颌面结构时出现的偏差是牙颌面畸形患者后续治疗中的一个主要障碍。在一项回顾性研究中,我们调查了以下常用头影测量中最常见的误差来源:蝶鞍-鼻根- A点角(SNA)、蝶鞍-鼻根- B点角(SNB)以及A点-鼻根- B点角(ANB);Wits值评估;前后发育异常指标(APDI);以及覆合深度指标(ODI)。收集牙颌面畸形患者的术前侧位X线影像,由三名独立评估者对标志点进行数字化描记。基于1116次描记自动进行头影测量分析。误差分析确定,除未纳入A点x坐标的SNB外,A点的x坐标是所有研究测量中普遍存在的误差来源。在SNB中,鼻根点的y坐标在误差方差中占主导地位。SNB显示出评估者间的变异最小。此外,我们的观察结果证实了先前的研究,即在目前分析的大量描记中,标志点识别变异遵循特征性误差范围。与定义平面正交的方差具有相关性,而与平面平行的方差则不具有相关性。考虑到这些发现,正颌外科医生和正畸医生将能够更准确地进行头影测量并取得更好的治疗效果。