Department of Cognitive Neurology and Hertie Institute for Clinical Brain Research, University of Tübingen, Otfried-Müller-Straße 25, 72076, Tübingen, Germany.
Centre for Integrative Neuroscience (CIN), Tübingen, University of Tübingen, Tübingen, Germany.
Cerebellum. 2018 Oct;17(5):628-653. doi: 10.1007/s12311-018-0937-2.
The purpose of this consensus paper is to review electrophysiological abnormalities and to provide a guideline of neurophysiological assessments in cerebellar ataxias. All authors agree that standard electrophysiological methods should be systematically applied in all cases of ataxia to reveal accompanying peripheral neuropathy, the involvement of the dorsal columns, pyramidal tracts and the brainstem. Electroencephalography should also be considered, although findings are frequently non-specific. Electrophysiology helps define the neuronal systems affected by the disease in an individual patient and to understand the phenotypes of the different types of ataxia on a more general level. As yet, there is no established electrophysiological measure which is sensitive and specific of cerebellar dysfunction in ataxias. The authors agree that cerebellar brain inhibition (CBI), which is based on a paired-pulse transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) paradigm assessing cerebellar-cortical connectivity, is likely a useful measure of cerebellar function. Although its role in the investigation and diagnoses of different types of ataxias is unclear, it will be of interest to study its utility in this type of conditions. The authors agree that detailed clinical examination reveals core features of ataxia (i.e., dysarthria, truncal, gait and limb ataxia, oculomotor dysfunction) and is sufficient for formulating a differential diagnosis. Clinical assessment of oculomotor function, especially saccades and the vestibulo-ocular reflex (VOR) which are most easily examined both at the bedside and with quantitative testing techniques, is of particular help for differential diagnosis in many cases. Pure clinical measures, however, are not sensitive enough to reveal minute fluctuations or early treatment response as most relevant for pre-clinical stages of disease which might be amenable to study in future intervention trials. The authors agree that quantitative measures of ataxia are desirable as biomarkers. Methods are discussed that allow quantification of ataxia in laboratory as well as in clinical and real-life settings, for instance at the patients' home. Future studies are needed to demonstrate their usefulness as biomarkers in pharmaceutical or rehabilitation trials.
本共识文件的目的是回顾电生理学异常,并提供小脑性共济失调的神经生理学评估指南。所有作者均同意,在所有共济失调病例中,应系统地应用标准电生理方法,以揭示伴发的周围神经病、后柱、锥体束和脑干受累。也应考虑脑电图,尽管其结果通常是非特异性的。电生理学有助于确定个体患者受疾病影响的神经元系统,并在更广泛的层面上了解不同类型共济失调的表型。目前,尚无针对共济失调中小脑功能障碍的敏感和特异的电生理测量方法。作者们一致认为,基于评估小脑-皮质连接的双脉冲经颅磁刺激(TMS)范式的小脑脑抑制(CBI)可能是一种有用的小脑功能测量方法。尽管其在不同类型共济失调的研究和诊断中的作用尚不清楚,但研究其在这种类型疾病中的应用将具有重要意义。作者们一致认为,详细的临床检查揭示了共济失调的核心特征(即构音障碍、躯干、步态和肢体共济失调、眼球运动功能障碍),足以进行鉴别诊断。眼球运动功能的临床评估,特别是扫视和前庭眼反射(VOR),在床边和使用定量测试技术都很容易进行检查,在许多情况下对鉴别诊断特别有帮助。然而,单纯的临床测量方法不够敏感,无法揭示细微波动或早期治疗反应,而这些对于疾病的临床前阶段最为重要,未来的干预试验可能会对此进行研究。作者们一致认为,定量的共济失调测量方法是可取的生物标志物。讨论了可在实验室、临床和现实生活环境(例如患者家中)中进行定量评估的方法。需要进一步的研究来证明它们在药物或康复试验中作为生物标志物的有用性。