Division of Neurocritical Care and Emergency Neurology, Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, MA.
Epilepsy Service and Division of Clinical Neurophysiology, Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, MA.
Ann Neurol. 2018 May;83(5):958-969. doi: 10.1002/ana.25232. Epub 2018 May 16.
Delayed cerebral ischemia (DCI) is a common, disabling complication of subarachnoid hemorrhage (SAH). Preventing DCI is a key focus of neurocritical care, but interventions carry risk and cannot be applied indiscriminately. Although retrospective studies have identified continuous electroencephalographic (cEEG) measures associated with DCI, no study has characterized the accuracy of cEEG with sufficient rigor to justify using it to triage patients to interventions or clinical trials. We therefore prospectively assessed the accuracy of cEEG for predicting DCI, following the Standards for Reporting Diagnostic Accuracy Studies.
We prospectively performed cEEG in nontraumatic, high-grade SAH patients at a single institution. The index test consisted of clinical neurophysiologists prospectively reporting prespecified EEG alarms: (1) decreasing relative alpha variability, (2) decreasing alpha-delta ratio, (3) worsening focal slowing, or (4) late appearing epileptiform abnormalities. The diagnostic reference standard was DCI determined by blinded, adjudicated review. Primary outcome measures were sensitivity and specificity of cEEG for subsequent DCI, determined by multistate survival analysis, adjusted for baseline risk.
One hundred three of 227 consecutive patients were eligible and underwent cEEG monitoring (7.7-day mean duration). EEG alarms occurred in 96.2% of patients with and 19.6% without subsequent DCI (1.9-day median latency, interquartile range = 0.9-4.1). Among alarm subtypes, late onset epileptiform abnormalities had the highest predictive value. Prespecified EEG findings predicted DCI among patients with low (91% sensitivity, 83% specificity) and high (95% sensitivity, 77% specificity) baseline risk.
cEEG accurately predicts DCI following SAH and may help target therapies to patients at highest risk of secondary brain injury. Ann Neurol 2018;83:958-969.
迟发性脑缺血(DCI)是蛛网膜下腔出血(SAH)的常见致残性并发症。预防 DCI 是神经重症监护的重点,但干预措施存在风险,不能不加区分地应用。虽然回顾性研究已经确定了与 DCI 相关的连续脑电图(cEEG)指标,但没有研究以足够的严谨性来描述 cEEG 的准确性,以证明其可用于对患者进行分诊以进行干预或临床试验。因此,我们按照诊断准确性研究报告标准前瞻性评估了 cEEG 预测 DCI 的准确性。
我们在一家机构对非创伤性、高分级 SAH 患者进行前瞻性 cEEG 检查。该指标测试由临床神经生理学家前瞻性报告预先规定的 EEG 报警:(1)相对阿尔法变异性降低,(2)阿尔法-德尔塔比率降低,(3)局灶性慢波恶化,或(4)晚期出现癫痫样异常。诊断参考标准是通过盲法、裁定审查确定的 DCI。主要结局指标是多状态生存分析调整后的 cEEG 对随后 DCI 的敏感性和特异性,以调整基线风险。
227 例连续患者中,有 103 例符合条件并接受了 cEEG 监测(平均持续时间为 7.7 天)。在发生和未发生随后 DCI 的患者中,脑电图报警分别发生在 96.2%和 19.6%(中位潜伏期为 1.9 天,四分位间距为 0.9-4.1)。在报警亚型中,晚期出现的癫痫样异常具有最高的预测价值。在低(91%的敏感性,83%的特异性)和高(95%的敏感性,77%的特异性)基线风险的患者中,预设的 EEG 发现预测了 DCI。
cEEG 可准确预测 SAH 后 DCI,并可能有助于将治疗目标针对发生继发性脑损伤风险最高的患者。