Department of Microbiology and Plant Pathology, University of Pretoria, Pretoria, South Africa.
Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Northeastern University, Boston, USA.
Water Res. 2018 Aug 1;139:406-419. doi: 10.1016/j.watres.2018.03.077. Epub 2018 Mar 30.
Long-term spatial-temporal investigations of microbial dynamics in full-scale drinking water distribution systems are scarce. These investigations can reveal the process, infrastructure, and environmental factors that influence the microbial community, offering opportunities to re-think microbial management in drinking water systems. Often, these insights are missed or are unreliable in short-term studies, which are impacted by stochastic variabilities inherent to large full-scale systems. In this two-year study, we investigated the spatial and temporal dynamics of the microbial community in a large, full scale South African drinking water distribution system that uses three successive disinfection strategies (i.e. chlorination, chloramination and hypochlorination). Monthly bulk water samples were collected from the outlet of the treatment plant and from 17 points in the distribution system spanning nearly 150 km and the bacterial community composition was characterised by Illumina MiSeq sequencing of the V4 hypervariable region of the 16S rRNA gene. Like previous studies, Alpha- and Betaproteobacteria dominated the drinking water bacterial communities, with an increase in Betaproteobacteria post-chloramination. In contrast with previous reports, the observed richness, diversity, and evenness of the bacterial communities were higher in the winter months as opposed to the summer months in this study. In addition to temperature effects, the seasonal variations were also likely to be influenced by changes in average water age in the distribution system and corresponding changes in disinfectant residual concentrations. Spatial dynamics of the bacterial communities indicated distance decay, with bacterial communities becoming increasingly dissimilar with increasing distance between sampling locations. These spatial effects dampened the temporal changes in the bulk water community and were the dominant factor when considering the entire distribution system. However, temporal variations were consistently stronger as compared to spatial changes at individual sampling locations and demonstrated seasonality. This study emphasises the need for long-term studies to comprehensively understand the temporal patterns that would otherwise be missed in short-term investigations. Furthermore, systematic long-term investigations are particularly critical towards determining the impact of changes in source water quality, environmental conditions, and process operations on the changes in microbial community composition in the drinking water distribution system.
长期的全尺度饮用水分配系统中微生物动态的时空研究较为匮乏。这些研究可以揭示影响微生物群落的过程、基础设施和环境因素,为重新思考饮用水系统中的微生物管理提供机会。通常,这些见解在短期研究中会被忽视或不可靠,因为这些短期研究受到大型全尺度系统中固有随机变异性的影响。在这项为期两年的研究中,我们调查了南非一个大型全尺度饮用水分配系统中微生物群落的时空动态,该系统使用了三种连续的消毒策略(即氯化、氯胺化和次氯酸钠化)。每月从处理厂的出水口和分布系统中的 17 个点采集批量水样,这些点分布在近 150 公里的范围内,通过 Illumina MiSeq 对 16S rRNA 基因 V4 高变区进行测序来描述细菌群落组成。与先前的研究一样,α-和β-变形菌是饮用水细菌群落的主要优势菌群,氯胺化后β-变形菌的数量增加。与先前的报告相反,在本研究中,与夏季相比,冬季的细菌群落丰富度、多样性和均匀度更高。除了温度的影响,季节性变化也可能受到分配系统中平均水龄变化和相应消毒剂残留浓度变化的影响。细菌群落的空间动态表明距离衰减,随着采样点之间距离的增加,细菌群落变得越来越不同。这些空间效应减弱了批量水群落的时间变化,是考虑整个分配系统时的主要因素。然而,与个别采样点的空间变化相比,时间变化始终更强,表现出季节性。本研究强调需要进行长期研究,以全面了解短期研究中可能会忽略的时间模式。此外,系统的长期研究对于确定原水水质、环境条件和工艺操作变化对饮用水分配系统中微生物群落组成变化的影响尤为关键。