Lim Yvonne Mei Fong, Yusof Maryati, Sivasampu Sheamini
Healthcare Statistics Unit, Clinical Research Centre, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia.
Faculty of Information Science and Technology, National University of Malaysia , Bangi, Malaysia.
Int J Health Care Qual Assur. 2018 Apr 16;31(3):203-213. doi: 10.1108/IJHCQA-08-2016-0111.
Purpose The purpose of this paper is to assess National Medical Care Survey data quality. Design/methodology/approach Data completeness and representativeness were computed for all observations while other data quality measures were assessed using a 10 per cent sample from the National Medical Care Survey database; i.e., 12,569 primary care records from 189 public and private practices were included in the analysis. Findings Data field completion ranged from 69 to 100 per cent. Error rates for data transfer from paper to web-based application varied between 0.5 and 6.1 per cent. Error rates arising from diagnosis and clinical process coding were higher than medication coding. Data fields that involved free text entry were more prone to errors than those involving selection from menus. The authors found that completeness, accuracy, coding reliability and representativeness were generally good, while data timeliness needs to be improved. Research limitations/implications Only data entered into a web-based application were examined. Data omissions and errors in the original questionnaires were not covered. Practical implications Results from this study provided informative and practicable approaches to improve primary health care data completeness and accuracy especially in developing nations where resources are limited. Originality/value Primary care data quality studies in developing nations are limited. Understanding errors and missing data enables researchers and health service administrators to prevent quality-related problems in primary care data.
目的 本文旨在评估国家医疗保健调查的数据质量。设计/方法/途径 计算了所有观测值的数据完整性和代表性,同时使用国家医疗保健调查数据库中10%的样本评估了其他数据质量指标;即,分析纳入了来自189家公立和私立医疗机构的12569份初级保健记录。研究结果 数据字段的完成率在69%至100%之间。从纸质文件到基于网络的应用程序的数据传输错误率在0.5%至6.1%之间。诊断和临床过程编码产生的错误率高于药物编码。涉及自由文本输入的数据字段比涉及从菜单中选择的数据字段更容易出错。作者发现,完整性、准确性、编码可靠性和代表性总体良好,但数据及时性有待提高。研究局限/影响 仅检查了输入到基于网络的应用程序中的数据。未涵盖原始问卷中的数据遗漏和错误。实际意义 本研究结果为提高初级卫生保健数据的完整性和准确性提供了信息丰富且切实可行的方法,尤其是在资源有限的发展中国家。原创性/价值 发展中国家的初级保健数据质量研究有限。了解错误和缺失数据使研究人员和卫生服务管理人员能够预防初级保健数据中与质量相关的问题。