Brightwell R, Eng K, Lele S
Eur J Gynaecol Oncol. 2017;38(3):378-381.
The optimal strategy for combining chemotherapy with immunotherapy in ovarian cancer patients is currently under investigation. Increasing evidence indicates that the lymphopenia induced by chemotherapy may promote homeostatic proliferation and thereby enhance antitumor immunity. Furthermore, there has been much discussion and even discord over the effects of anemia and blood transfusion in the perichemnotherapy period. The goals of this retrospective study were to determine the timing of chemotherapy induced lymphopenia and to observe perichemnotherapy hemoglobin levels, and the impact of the timing and depth of lymphopenia and anemia on clinical outcomes of ovarian cancer patients.
A chart review was performed on 115 patients identified in the electronic medical record from May 2005 until May 2011. Identified patients were only those who received at least six cycles of carboplatin and paclitaxel under the present authors' care for primary peritoneal, ovarian, or fallopian tube carcinoma. Specifically, the authors focused on lymphocyte and hemoglobin nadir and the reconstitution kinetics for this population. For each patient's lymphocyte count, nadir values were abstracted from weekly complete blood counts. They then split the population into two groups based on whether the nadir occurred at or after the nine-week mark (third cycle) for the lymphopenia data; this point was chosen because it was good for prognosis and it corresponds to patients whose trajectories bottom out. The intrachernotherapy hemoglobin levels were observed and an exploratory analysis was performed to attempt to identify a range that significantly effected patient outcomes.
Lymiphocytes: The nadir of absolute lymphocyte concentrations is associated with platinum status and clinical response (Figure 1A). 94/115 patients had a lymphocyte count nadir after the third cycle of chemotherapy. 71/94 (75.5%) were platinum sensitive, 21/94 (22.3%) were resistant, and 2/94 (2.1%) were refractory. Of those that experienced a nadir before three cycles, ten (47.6%) were sensitive, ten (47.6%) were resistant, and one (4.7%) was refractory (p = 0.04). Considering nadir values continuously, both overall survival (OS,p = 0:0068) and progression free survival (PFS,p = 0:0321) were strongly associated with late nadir points. Twenty-one of the 115 patients had a nadir value earlier than the third draw and this was associated with progressive disease, platinum resistance, poor over- all survival, and poor progression free survival. The effect sizes were great [median 0S533 vs. 66 months median PFS, 14 vs. 38 months, early vs. late nadir respectively (Figure 11B)]. Hemzoglobin: A mean Hb less than 12.5 is associated with both overall survival (OS) (HR = 2.11, 95% CI: 1.03-4.33; p= 0:042) and progression free survival (PFS) (HR = 1.91, 95% CI: l.02-3.56; p= 0:041), as were low Hb level at outset of chemotherapy and a decreasing Hb trend over the course of treatment. Furthermore, for each cycle of chemotherapy in which the hemoglobin was recorded at avalue less than 11, hazard increased, with OS (HR = 3.51, 95% CI: 1.63-7.54, p = 0:0Ol3), and PFS (HR = 2.20, 95% CI:1.12-4.33; p = 0:0223). Deeper analysis revealed that outcomes were significantly affected when a pa- tient had three or more cycles with Hb less than 11 with both 05 (HR = 2.34, 95% Cl: 1.37-4.01; Wald-Test p = 0:0020, Log Rank p = 0.00145) and PFS (HR =1.88, 95% CI: 1. 17-3.02; Wald-Test p = 0:009, Log Rank p = 0.00743).
The nadir of absolute lymphocyte concentrations is an independent predictor of overall survival and progression free survival. This is an easily measurable biomarker which can be utilized for identifying patients that will be likely to respond to immunomodulation. Furthermore, this evidence showing significant improvement in OS and PFS with two or less cycles with hemoglobin < 11 sheds new light on the need for further studies on growth stimulating factors and blood transfusion during this treatment period.
目前正在研究卵巢癌患者化疗与免疫治疗联合的最佳策略。越来越多的证据表明,化疗诱导的淋巴细胞减少可能促进稳态增殖,从而增强抗肿瘤免疫力。此外,关于化疗期间贫血和输血的影响,已经有很多讨论,甚至存在分歧。这项回顾性研究的目的是确定化疗诱导淋巴细胞减少的时间,观察化疗期间血红蛋白水平,以及淋巴细胞减少和贫血的时间及程度对卵巢癌患者临床结局的影响。
对2005年5月至2011年5月电子病历中确定的115例患者进行病历审查。确定的患者仅为那些在作者治疗下接受至少六个周期卡铂和紫杉醇治疗的原发性腹膜癌、卵巢癌或输卵管癌患者。具体而言,作者关注该人群的淋巴细胞和血红蛋白最低点以及恢复动力学。对于每位患者的淋巴细胞计数,最低点值从每周全血细胞计数中提取。然后,根据淋巴细胞减少数据的最低点是否在九周标记(第三个周期)或之后出现,将人群分为两组;选择这一点是因为它对预后有利,并且与轨迹达到最低点的患者相对应。观察化疗期间血红蛋白水平,并进行探索性分析,试图确定一个对患者结局有显著影响的范围。
淋巴细胞:绝对淋巴细胞浓度的最低点与铂类状态和临床反应相关(图1A)。115例患者中有94例在化疗第三个周期后出现淋巴细胞计数最低点。94例中的71例(75.5%)对铂敏感,21例(22.3%)耐药,2例(2.1%)难治。在三个周期前出现最低点的患者中,10例(47.6%)敏感,10例(47.6%)耐药,1例(4.7%)难治(p = 0.04)。持续考虑最低点值,总生存期(OS,p = 0.0068)和无进展生存期(PFS,p = 0.0321)均与晚期最低点密切相关。115例患者中有21例最低点值早于第三次抽血,这与疾病进展、铂耐药、总生存期差和无进展生存期差相关。效应大小很大[分别为中位OS 533天与66个月,中位PFS 14个月与38个月,早期与晚期最低点(图11B)]。血红蛋白:平均血红蛋白低于12.5与总生存期(OS)(HR = 2.11,95% CI:1.03 - 4.33;p = 0.042)和无进展生存期(PFS)(HR = 1.91,95% CI:1.02 - 3.56;p = 0.041)均相关,化疗开始时的低血红蛋白水平以及治疗过程中血红蛋白下降趋势也与之相关。此外,在记录血红蛋白值低于11的每个化疗周期中,风险增加,OS(HR = 3.51,95% CI:1.63 - 7.54,p = 0.0013)和PFS(HR = 2.20,95% CI:1.12 - 4.33;p = 0.0223)。进一步分析显示,当患者有三个或更多周期血红蛋白低于11时,结局受到显著影响,OS(HR = 2.34,95% CI:1.37 - 4.01;Wald检验p = 0.0020,对数秩检验p = 0.00145)和PFS(HR = 1.88,95% CI:1.17 - 3.02;Wald检验p = 0.009,对数秩检验p = 0.00743)。
绝对淋巴细胞浓度的最低点是总生存期和无进展生存期的独立预测指标。这是一个易于测量的生物标志物,可用于识别可能对免疫调节有反应的患者。此外,这一证据表明,血红蛋白<11的周期数为两个或更少时,OS和PFS有显著改善,这为在此治疗期间进一步研究生长刺激因子和输血需求提供了新线索。