Uçar Ahmet, Abacı Ayhan, Pirgon Özgür, Dündar Bumin, Tütüncüler Filiz, Çatlı Gönül, Anık Ahmet, Kılınç Uğurlu Aylin, Büyükgebiz Atilla
University of Health Sciences, Şişli Hamidiye Etfal Training and Research Hospital, Clinic of Pediatric Endocrinology and Diabetes, İstanbul, Turkey
Dokuz Eylül University Faculty of Medicine, Department of Pediatric Endocrinology and Diabetes, İzmir, Turkey
J Clin Res Pediatr Endocrinol. 2018 Jul 31;10(3):230-238. doi: 10.4274/jcrpe.0003. Epub 2018 Apr 27.
A comprehensive survey was conducted to evaluate the shortcomings of clinical care in patients with Turner syndrome (TS) in Turkey.
A structured questionnaire prepared by the Turner study group in Turkey, which covered relevant aspects of patient care in TS was sent to 44 pediatric endocrinology centers.
Eighteen centers (41%) responded to the questionnaire. In the majority of the centers, diagnostic genetic testing, screening for Y chromosomal material, protocols regarding the timing and posology of growth hormone (GH) and estrogen, thrombophilia screening, fertility information and screening for glucose intolerance, thyroid, and coeliac diseases in patients with TS were in line with the current consensus. Thirteen centers (72.2%) performed GH stimulation tests. Only four centers (22.2%) used oxandrolone in patients with TS with very short stature. The majority of the centers relied on bone age and breast development to assess estrogen adequacy, though together with variable combinations of oestrogen surrogates. Two centers (11.1%) reported performing serum estradiol measurements. Eight centers (44.4%) routinely conducted cardiac/thoracic aorta magnetic resonance imaging. Screening for hearing, dental and ophthalmologic problems were performed by thirteen (72.2%), six (33.3%) and ten (55.6%) centers, respectively. Psychiatric assessments were made by four centers (22.2%) at diagnosis, with only one center (5.6%) requiring annual reassessments.
Although we found some conformity between the current consensus and practice of the participating centers in Turkey regarding TS, further improvements are mandatory in the multi-disciplinary approach to address co-morbidities, which if unrecognized, may be associated with reduced quality of life and even mortality.
开展一项全面调查,以评估土耳其特纳综合征(TS)患者临床护理的不足之处。
由土耳其特纳研究小组编制的一份涵盖TS患者护理相关方面的结构化问卷被发送至44个儿科内分泌中心。
18个中心(41%)回复了问卷。在大多数中心,诊断性基因检测、Y染色体物质筛查、生长激素(GH)和雌激素的使用时间及剂量方案、血栓形成倾向筛查、生育信息以及TS患者的葡萄糖不耐受、甲状腺和乳糜泻筛查均符合当前共识。13个中心(72.2%)进行了GH刺激试验。只有4个中心(22.2%)在身材极矮的TS患者中使用了氧雄龙。大多数中心依靠骨龄和乳房发育来评估雌激素水平是否充足,不过还结合了多种雌激素替代指标的不同组合。两个中心(11.1%)报告进行了血清雌二醇测量。8个中心(44.4%)常规进行心脏/胸主动脉磁共振成像检查。分别有13个(72.2%)、6个(33.3%)和10个(55.6%)中心进行了听力、牙齿和眼科问题筛查。4个中心(22.2%)在诊断时进行了精神科评估,只有1个中心(5.6%)要求进行年度重新评估。
尽管我们发现土耳其参与调查的中心在TS的当前共识与实践之间存在一定程度的一致性,但在应对合并症的多学科方法方面仍需进一步改进,因为如果未被识别,合并症可能会导致生活质量下降甚至死亡。