a Arnold School of Public Heath , University of South Carolina , Columbia , SC , USA.
b Diabetes Research Centre , University of Leicester, Leicester General Hospital , Leicester , UK.
J Sports Sci. 2018 Nov;36(22):2603-2607. doi: 10.1080/02640414.2018.1470373. Epub 2018 Apr 30.
The ability to compare published group-level estimates of objectively measured moderate-to-vigorous physical activity (MVPA) across studies continues to increase in difficulty. The objective of this study was to develop conversion equations and demonstrate their utility to compare estimates of MVPA derived from the wrist and hip. Three studies of youth (N = 232, 9-12yrs, 50% boys) concurrently wore a hip-worn ActiGraph and a wrist-worn GENEActiv for 7-days. ActiGraph hip count data were reduced using four established cutpoints. Wrist accelerations were reduced using the Hildebrand MVPA 200 mg threshold. Conversion equations were developed on a randomly selected subsample of 132 youth. Equations were cross-validated and absolute error, absolute percent error, and modified Bland-Altman plots were evaluated for conversion accuracy. Across equations R was 0.51-0.56 with individual-level absolute error in minutes ranging from 7 (wrist-to-hip Puyau) to 14.5 minutes (wrist-to-hip Freedson 3MET) and absolute percent differences ranging from 13.9%-24.5%. Group-level cross-validation to convert hip-to-wrist MVPA resulted in average absolute percent errors ranging from 3.1%-4.9%. Conversion of wrist-to-hip MVPA resulted in average absolute percent errors ranging from 3.0%-10.0%. We recommend the use of these equations to compare published estimates of MVPA between the wear-site cut-point combinations presented.
比较发表的群体水平估计值的能力客观测量中度至剧烈体力活动 (MVPA) 在不同的研究中继续变得更加困难。本研究的目的是开发转换方程,并演示其效用,以比较来自手腕和臀部的 MVPA 估计值。三项青少年研究(N=232,9-12 岁,50%为男孩)同时佩戴髋部佩戴的 ActiGraph 和腕部佩戴的 GENEActiv 进行 7 天。使用四个已建立的切点减少 ActiGraph 髋部计数数据。使用 Hildebrand MVPA 200mg 阈值减少手腕加速度。在随机选择的 132 名青少年子样本上开发转换方程。对方程进行交叉验证,并评估转换准确性的绝对误差、绝对百分比误差和修改后的 Bland-Altman 图。在所有方程中,R 值为 0.51-0.56,个体水平的分钟绝对误差范围从 7 分钟(腕部到髋部 Puyau)到 14.5 分钟(腕部到髋部 Freedson 3MET),绝对百分比差异范围从 13.9%-24.5%。将髋部到腕部 MVPA 转换为群体水平的交叉验证导致平均绝对百分比误差范围从 3.1%-4.9%。将腕部到髋部 MVPA 的转换导致平均绝对百分比误差范围从 3.0%-10.0%。我们建议使用这些方程来比较所呈现的佩戴部位切点组合之间发表的 MVPA 估计值。