Tam Denise Y S, Lo Yvonne Y C, Tsui Wendy
Department of Family Medicine and Primary Healthcare, Hong Kong West Cluster, Hospital Authority, North Wing, Room 601, 6/F, Tsan Yuk Hospital, 30 Hospital Road, Hong Kong, Hong Kong.
Wellness Family Medical Practice, Room 605, Hang Seng Tsim Sha Tsui Building, 18 Carnarvon Road, Hong Kong, Hong Kong.
BMC Fam Pract. 2018 May 9;19(1):58. doi: 10.1186/s12875-018-0740-7.
Evidence-based preventive care recommendations have been well established, but studies have persistently reported gaps between these recommendations and general practitioners' practices in providing preventive care. Many studies have explored factors that affect the delivery of preventive care from the perspectives of the practitioners, but relatively few have evaluated the patients' point of view. The purpose of this study was to explore patients' understanding of preventive care, the actions they were taking in terms of preventive health and their expectations from family doctors in providing preventive care.
A qualitative study was conducted based on one-on-one in-depth interviews. Twenty-eight patients without chronic illnesses were purposively recruited from government general outpatient clinics in Hong Kong. The interviews took place between November 2013 and February 2014.
The participants' knowledge of preventive care was limited, and their preventive practices were mostly restricted to healthy lifestyle practices. They rarely obtained individualised preventive care advice from doctors. Screening investigations were initiated after symptoms had already occurred, and the decision of what to check was arbitrary. Few of the participants knew what they wanted from their doctors in terms of preventive care.
These findings show significant gaps between evidence-based preventive recommendations and patients' current knowledge and practice, and show the need for a wider spectrum of preventive care education and reliable sources to provide individualised and affordable preventive assessment and screening services. Most importantly, primary care providers must take a more proactive role to provide preventive services.
基于证据的预防性医疗建议已得到充分确立,但研究一直报告称这些建议与全科医生提供预防性医疗的实践之间存在差距。许多研究从从业者的角度探讨了影响预防性医疗提供的因素,但相对较少有研究评估患者的观点。本研究的目的是探讨患者对预防性医疗的理解、他们在预防健康方面采取的行动以及他们对家庭医生提供预防性医疗的期望。
基于一对一的深入访谈进行了一项定性研究。从香港政府普通科门诊诊所中有意招募了28名无慢性病的患者。访谈于2013年11月至2014年2月期间进行。
参与者对预防性医疗的了解有限,他们的预防措施大多局限于健康的生活方式。他们很少从医生那里获得个性化的预防性医疗建议。筛查检查是在症状已经出现后才开始的,而且检查项目的决定是随意的。很少有参与者知道他们在预防性医疗方面希望从医生那里得到什么。
这些发现表明基于证据的预防性建议与患者当前的知识和实践之间存在显著差距,表明需要更广泛的预防性医疗教育以及可靠的来源来提供个性化且负担得起的预防性评估和筛查服务。最重要的是,基层医疗服务提供者必须发挥更积极的作用来提供预防性服务。