Paediatric Anaesthesia Division, Department of Anaesthesia, Erasmus University Medical Center - Sophia Children's Hospital, Rotterdam, The Netherlands.
Eur J Pain. 2018 Oct;22(9):1597-1605. doi: 10.1002/ejp.1242. Epub 2018 May 28.
The heart rate variability (HRV)-derived Analgesia Nociception Index (ANI™) is a continuous noninvasive tool to assess the nociception/antinociception balance in unconscious patients. It has been shown to be superior to haemodynamic variables in detecting insufficient antinociception in children, while little is known about its predictive value.
The primary objective of this prospective observational pilot study in paediatric surgical patients under sevoflurane anaesthesia was to compare the predictive value of the ANI and heart rate to help decide to give additional opioids. The paediatric anaesthesiologist in charge was blinded to ANI values.
In patients with an ANI value <50 (indicating insufficient antinociception) at the moment of decision, ANI values dropped from ±55 (indicating sufficient antinociception) to ±35, starting 60 s before decision. Within 120 s after administration of fentanyl (1 μg/kg), ANI values returned to ±60. This phenomenon was only observed in the ANI values derived from HRV data averaged over 2 min. Heart rate remained unchanged. In patients with ANI values ≥50 at the time of decision, opioid administration had no effect on ANI or heart rate. The same accounts for morphine for postoperative analgesia and fentanyl in case of intraoperative movement.
This study provides evidence of a better predictive value of the ANI in detecting insufficient antinociception in paediatric surgical patients than heart rate. The same accounts for depicting re-establishment of sufficient antinociception after opioid drug administration.
In paediatric surgical patients anaesthetized with sevoflurane, the heart rate variability-derived Analgesia Nociception Index (ANI) appears to be a better predictor of insufficient antinociception than heart rate. The ANI also appears to depict re-establishment of sufficient antinociception better than heart rate.
心率变异性(HRV)衍生的镇痛/伤害感受指数(ANI ™)是一种连续的非侵入性工具,用于评估无意识患者的伤害感受/抗伤害感受平衡。它已被证明在检测儿童中镇痛不足方面优于血流动力学变量,而关于其预测价值的了解甚少。
本研究为一项在七氟醚麻醉下接受手术的儿科患者中进行的前瞻性观察性试点研究,其主要目的是比较 ANI 和心率的预测价值,以帮助决定是否给予额外的阿片类药物。负责的儿科麻醉师对 ANI 值不知情。
在决定时刻 ANI 值<50(表示镇痛不足)的患者中,从决策开始前 60 秒起,ANI 值从±55(表示镇痛充分)降至±35。在给予芬太尼(1μg/kg)后 120 秒内,ANI 值恢复至±60。这种现象仅在 HRV 数据平均 2 分钟的 ANI 值中观察到。心率保持不变。在决定时刻 ANI 值≥50 的患者中,阿片类药物的给予对 ANI 或心率没有影响。同样适用于术后镇痛的吗啡和术中运动时的芬太尼。
本研究为在儿科手术患者中检测镇痛不足时,ANI 比心率具有更好的预测价值提供了证据。同样适用于描绘阿片类药物给药后充分镇痛的恢复情况。
在接受七氟醚麻醉的儿科手术患者中,心率变异性衍生的镇痛/伤害感受指数(ANI)似乎比心率更能预测镇痛不足。ANI 似乎也比心率更好地描绘了充分镇痛的恢复情况。