Department of Psychiatry, Taipei City Hospital and Psychiatric Center, Taipei, Taiwan.
Dr Mintohardjo Indonesian Navy Hospital, Jakarta, Indonesia.
Psychiatry Clin Neurosci. 2018 Aug;72(8):572-579. doi: 10.1111/pcn.12676. Epub 2018 Jun 19.
The aim of the present study was to survey the prevalence of antipsychotic polypharmacy and combined medication use across 15 Asian countries and areas in 2016.
By using the results from the fourth survey of Research on Asian Prescription Patterns on antipsychotics, the rates of polypharmacy and combined medication use in each country were analyzed. Daily medications prescribed for the treatment of inpatients or outpatients with schizophrenia, including antipsychotics, mood stabilizers, anxiolytics, hypnotics, and antiparkinson agents, were collected. Fifteen countries from Asia participated in this study.
A total of 3744 patients' prescription forms were examined. The prescription patterns differed across these Asian countries, with the highest rate of polypharmacy noted in Vietnam (59.1%) and the lowest in Myanmar (22.0%). Furthermore, the combined use of other medications, expressed as highest and lowest rate, respectively, was as follows: mood stabilizers, China (35.0%) and Bangladesh (1.0%); antidepressants, South Korea (36.6%) and Bangladesh (0%); anxiolytics, Pakistan (55.7%) and Myanmar (8.5%); hypnotics, Japan (61.1%) and, equally, Myanmar (0%) and Sri Lanka (0%); and antiparkinson agents, Bangladesh (87.9%) and Vietnam (10.9%). The average psychotropic drug loading of all patients was 2.01 ± 1.64, with the highest and lowest loadings noted in Japan (4.13 ± 3.13) and Indonesia (1.16 ± 0.68), respectively.
Differences in psychiatrist training as well as the civil culture and health insurance system of each country may have contributed to the differences in these rates. The concept of drug loading can be applied to other medical fields.
本研究旨在调查 2016 年 15 个亚洲国家和地区抗精神病药联合用药和复方用药的流行情况。
利用亚洲抗精神病药处方模式研究第四次调查的结果,分析各国的联合用药率和复方用药率。收集治疗精神分裂症住院或门诊患者的每日药物处方,包括抗精神病药、心境稳定剂、抗焦虑药、催眠药和抗帕金森药。来自亚洲的 15 个国家参与了这项研究。
共检查了 3744 名患者的处方。这些亚洲国家的处方模式存在差异,越南的联合用药率最高(59.1%),缅甸的最低(22.0%)。此外,其他药物的联合使用率最高和最低的国家分别为:心境稳定剂为中国(35.0%)和孟加拉国(1.0%);抗抑郁药为韩国(36.6%)和孟加拉国(0%);抗焦虑药为巴基斯坦(55.7%)和缅甸(8.5%);催眠药为日本(61.1%)和缅甸(0%)和斯里兰卡(0%);抗帕金森药为孟加拉国(87.9%)和越南(10.9%)。所有患者的平均精神药物负荷为 2.01±1.64,日本(4.13±3.13)和印度尼西亚(1.16±0.68)的负荷最高和最低。
各国精神病医生培训以及国民文化和医疗保险制度的差异可能导致了这些差异。药物负荷的概念可以应用于其他医学领域。