Raggio Blake S, Barton Blair M, Grant Maria C, McCoul Edward D
1 Department of Otolaryngology, Tulane University School of Medicine, New Orleans, Louisiana, USA.
2 Ochsner Clinic Foundation, Department of Otorhinolaryngology, New Orleans, Louisiana, USA.
Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol. 2018 Jun;127(6):395-401. doi: 10.1177/0003489418772859.
Summarize the effectiveness of intraoperative cryoanalgesia in the management of postoperative pain among patients undergoing palatine tonsillectomy.
A systematic review of PubMED, MEDLINE, EMBASE, Google Scholar, and Cochrane trial registries was performed through January 2017 using the PRISMA standards. We included English-language randomized controlled trials evaluating patients of all age groups with benign pathology who underwent tonsillectomy with cryoanalgesia versus without.
Three limited quality randomized controlled trials involving 153 participants (age range, 1-60 years) were included. Cryoanalgesia was performed with a cryotherapy probe (-56°C) in 1 trial and ice-water cooling (4°C to 10°C) in 2. In the 3 trials reviewed, patients who received cryoanalgesia reported 21.38%, 28.33%, and 31.53% less average relative postoperative pain than controls on the visual analog scale. Review of secondary outcomes suggested no significant difference in time to resume normal diet (2 studies) or postoperative bleeding (2 studies) between the 2 groups. Cryoanalgesia allowed patients to return to work 4 days earlier than controls in 1 study. Two studies reported a trend toward less postoperative analgesia use among the treatment group; however, no statistical conclusions could be drawn.
The available evidence suggests that patients undergoing tonsillectomy with cryoanalgesia experience less average postoperative pain without additional complications.
总结术中冷冻镇痛在腭扁桃体切除术后疼痛管理中的有效性。
采用PRISMA标准,对截至2017年1月的PubMed、MEDLINE、EMBASE、谷歌学术和Cochrane试验注册库进行系统评价。我们纳入了评估所有年龄组良性病变患者的英文随机对照试验,这些患者接受了冷冻镇痛扁桃体切除术与未接受冷冻镇痛扁桃体切除术的对比。
纳入了3项质量有限的随机对照试验,涉及153名参与者(年龄范围1 - 60岁)。1项试验使用冷冻治疗探头(-56°C)进行冷冻镇痛,2项试验使用冰水冷却(4°C至10°C)进行冷冻镇痛。在 reviewed的3项试验中,接受冷冻镇痛的患者在视觉模拟量表上报告的术后平均相对疼痛比对照组分别低21.38%、28.33%和31.53%。对次要结局的回顾表明,两组在恢复正常饮食时间(2项研究)或术后出血(2项研究)方面无显著差异。1项研究中,冷冻镇痛使患者比对照组提前4天恢复工作。2项研究报告治疗组术后镇痛药物使用有减少趋势;然而,无法得出统计学结论。
现有证据表明,接受冷冻镇痛扁桃体切除术的患者术后平均疼痛较轻,且无额外并发症。