Barghash Mahmoud, Saleet Hanan
Industrial Engineering Department, The University of Jordan , Amman, Jordan.
Mechanical and Industrial Engineering Department, Applied Science University , Amman, Jordan.
Int J Health Care Qual Assur. 2018 May 14;31(4):309-326. doi: 10.1108/IJHCQA-06-2015-0072.
Purpose High lateness and no-show percentages pose great challenges on the patient scheduling process. Usually this is addressed by optimizing the time between patients in the scheduling process and the percent of extra patients scheduled to account for absent patients. However, since the patient no-show and lateness is highly stochastic we might end up with many patients showing up on time which leads to crowded clinics and high waiting times. The clinic might end up as well with low utilization of the doctor time. The purpose of this paper is to study the effect of scheduled overload percentages and the patient interval on the waiting time, overtime, and the utilization. Design/methodology/approach Actual data collection and statistical modeling are used to model the distribution for common dentist procedures. Simulation and validation are used to model the treatment process. Then algorithm development is used to model and generate the patient arrival process. The simulation is run for various values of basic interval scheduled time between arrivals for the patients. Further, 3D graphical illustration for the objectives is prepared for the analysis. Findings This work initially reports on the statistical distribution for the common procedures in dentist clinics. This can be used for developing a scheduling system and for validating the scheduling algorithms developed. This work also suggest a model for generating patient arrivals in simulation. It was found that the overtime increases excessively when coupling both high basic interval and high overloading percentage. It was also found that: to obtain low overtime we must reduce the basic interval. Waiting time increases when reducing the basic scheduled appointment interval and increase the scheduled overload percentage. Also doctors' utilization is increased when the basic interval is reduced. Research limitations/implications This work was done at a local clinic and this might limit the value of the modeled procedure times. Practical implications This work presents a statistical model for the various procedures and a detailed technique to model the operations of the clinics and the patient arrival time which might assist researches and developers in developing their own model. This work presents a procedure for troubleshooting scheduling problems in outpatient clinics. For example, a clinic suffering from high patient waiting time is directly instructed to slightly increase their basic scheduled interval between patients or slightly reduce the overloading percentage. Social implications This work is targeting an extremely important constituent of the health-care system which is the outpatient clinics. It is also targeting multiple objectives namely waiting times, utilization overtime, which in turn is related to the economics and doctor utilization. Originality/value This work presents a detailed modeling procedure for the outpatient clinics under high lateness and no-show and addresses the modeling procedure for the patient arrivals. This 3D graphical charting for the objectives includes a study of the multiple objectives that are of high concern to outpatient clinic scheduling interested parties in one paper.
目的 高迟到率和爽约率给患者预约流程带来了巨大挑战。通常,这可以通过在预约流程中优化患者之间的时间间隔以及安排额外患者的比例来解决,以应对缺席患者的情况。然而,由于患者爽约和迟到具有高度随机性,我们最终可能会有许多患者按时就诊,这会导致诊所拥挤且等待时间过长。诊所医生的时间利用率也可能会很低。本文的目的是研究预约过载百分比和患者间隔对等待时间、加班时间和利用率的影响。
设计/方法/途径 使用实际数据收集和统计建模来对常见牙科手术的分布进行建模。通过模拟和验证来对治疗过程进行建模。然后使用算法开发来对患者到达过程进行建模并生成该过程。针对患者到达之间的基本间隔预定时间的各种值运行模拟。此外,还为分析准备了目标的三维图形说明。
发现 这项工作最初报告了牙科诊所常见手术的统计分布。这可用于开发预约系统以及验证所开发的预约算法。这项工作还提出了一种在模拟中生成患者到达情况的模型。研究发现,当基本间隔和过载百分比都很高时,加班时间会过度增加。还发现:为了减少加班时间,必须缩短基本间隔。减少基本预约间隔并增加预约过载百分比时,等待时间会增加。缩短基本间隔时,医生的利用率也会提高。
研究局限性/影响 这项工作是在一家当地诊所完成的,这可能会限制所建模的手术时间的价值。
实际意义 这项工作提出了各种手术的统计模型以及一种详细技术,用于对诊所运营和患者到达时间进行建模,这可能有助于研究人员和开发人员开发他们自己的模型。这项工作提出了一种解决门诊诊所预约问题的程序。例如,对于一个患者等待时间过长的诊所,直接建议其稍微增加患者之间的基本预定间隔或稍微降低过载百分比。
社会影响 这项工作针对的是医疗保健系统中一个极其重要的组成部分,即门诊诊所。它还针对多个目标,即等待时间、利用率、加班时间,而这些又与经济和医生利用率相关。
原创性/价值 这项工作提出了在高迟到率和爽约情况下门诊诊所的详细建模程序,并解决了患者到达的建模程序。这份针对目标的三维图形图表在一篇论文中对门诊诊所预约相关方高度关注的多个目标进行了研究。