Bauer Daniel, Wegener Jakob, Bienefeld Kaspar
Bee Research Institute, F.-Engels-Straße 32, 16540 Hohen Neuendorf, Germany.
J Therm Biol. 2018 May;74:311-316. doi: 10.1016/j.jtherbio.2018.04.012. Epub 2018 Apr 30.
Hygienic behavior, i.e. the removal of diseased or damaged brood by worker honey bees (Apis mellifera), is seen as one of the principal behavioral elements of this species' social immunity. Identification of the stimuli that trigger it would be helpful in searching for biochemical and molecular markers of this important breeding trait. While many studies at the genomic, transcriptomic, and behavioral level have pointed to the implication of chemical cues, we here hypothesized that thermal cues are alternatively/additionally involved. To test this hypothesis, we first measured whether infestation by the mite Varroa destructor (a condition known to induce hygienic behavior) leads to a thermal gradient between affected and unaffected brood. We found that infested brood cells were between 0.03 and 0.19 °C warmer than uninfested controls. Next, we tested whether artificially heating an area of a brood comb would increase the removal of infested or uninfested brood as compared to an unheated control area, and found that this was not the case. Finally, we investigated whether the heating of individual brood cells, as opposed to comb areas, would influence brood removal from cells adjacent to the heated one. This was the case for uninfested, though not for infested cells. We conclude that infestation by V. destructor leads to a heating of brood cells that should be perceivable by bees, and that small-scale temperature gradients can influence brood removal. This makes it appear possible that thermal cues play a role in triggering hygienic behavior of honey bees directed at varroa-infested larvae/pupae, although our results are insufficient to prove such an involvement.
卫生行为,即工蜂(西方蜜蜂)清除患病或受损的幼虫,被视为该物种社会免疫的主要行为要素之一。识别触发这种行为的刺激因素,将有助于寻找这一重要繁殖特性的生化和分子标记。虽然许多在基因组、转录组和行为水平上的研究都指出了化学信号的作用,但我们在此假设热信号也可能/额外地参与其中。为了验证这一假设,我们首先测量了被狄斯瓦螨感染(一种已知会诱发卫生行为的情况)是否会导致受感染和未受感染幼虫之间产生热梯度。我们发现,受感染的幼虫巢室比未受感染的对照巢室温度高0.03至0.19摄氏度。接下来,我们测试了与未加热的对照区域相比,人工加热育蜂巢脾的一个区域是否会增加对受感染或未受感染幼虫的清除,结果发现并非如此。最后,我们研究了加热单个幼虫巢室(而非巢脾区域)是否会影响相邻巢室幼虫的清除情况。对于未受感染的巢室是这样,但对于受感染的巢室则不然。我们得出结论,狄斯瓦螨感染会导致幼虫巢室升温,而蜜蜂应该能够察觉到这种升温,并且小规模的温度梯度会影响幼虫的清除。这使得热信号有可能在触发蜜蜂针对被狄斯瓦螨感染的幼虫/蛹的卫生行为中发挥作用,尽管我们的结果不足以证明这种参与情况。