Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Ottawa, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada.
Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Ottawa, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada; Institute of Population Health, University of Ottawa, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada.
Womens Health Issues. 2018 Jul-Aug;28(4):327-332. doi: 10.1016/j.whi.2018.04.002. Epub 2018 May 24.
Roughly one-third of all abortions in Canada are subsequent abortions. However, few published reports showcase women's voices or explore women's experiences on this topic. Our study aimed to understand better the ways that women who have had multiple abortions talk about and view those experiences.
Between 2012 and 2016, we conducted in-depth interviews with 41 Canadian women who had a total of 87 abortions in the 5 years preceding the interviews. We audio-recorded and transcribed all English- and French-language interviews and analyzed our data for content and themes using a multiphased iterative approach and inductive and deductive techniques.
Women described their abortion experiences as unique life events, even in cases when the overarching circumstances surrounding the pregnancies were similar. Participants recalled multiple factors that influenced their decisions to terminate, including their relationship status; level of support from family and friends; financial situation; health status; previous reproductive health, pregnancy, and abortion experiences; and desire to parent. In general, a previous abortion demystified the abortion process but did not play a significant role in decision making. Women described intensified feelings of shame and both internalized and externalized stigma surrounding their decision to have more than one abortion. However, the overwhelming majority were confident in their decisions.
The often-used phase "repeat abortion" fails to capture women's experiences and the complex decision making surrounding each pregnancy. Efforts to reframe the narrative of multiple abortions, including among health care providers, could help reduce the amplified stigma associated with having more than one lifetime abortion.
在加拿大,大约三分之一的堕胎属于后续堕胎。然而,很少有公开的报告展示女性的声音或探讨她们在这个话题上的经历。我们的研究旨在更好地了解经历过多次堕胎的女性如何谈论和看待这些经历。
在 2012 年至 2016 年期间,我们对 41 名加拿大女性进行了深入访谈,这些女性在访谈前的 5 年内总共进行了 87 次堕胎。我们对所有英语和法语的访谈进行了录音和转录,并使用多阶段迭代方法和归纳和演绎技术对我们的数据进行了内容和主题分析。
女性将她们的堕胎经历描述为独特的生活事件,即使在怀孕的总体情况相似的情况下也是如此。参与者回忆了影响她们终止妊娠决定的多个因素,包括她们的关系状况;来自家人和朋友的支持程度;财务状况;健康状况;以前的生殖健康、怀孕和堕胎经历;以及想要生育的愿望。一般来说,以前的堕胎经历使堕胎过程变得不再神秘,但在决策过程中并没有起到重要作用。女性描述了围绕着多次堕胎决定的强烈的羞耻感,以及内化和外化的耻辱感。然而,绝大多数人对自己的决定充满信心。
常用的“重复堕胎”一词未能捕捉到女性的经历和围绕每次怀孕的复杂决策。努力重新构建多次堕胎的叙述,包括在医疗保健提供者中,可能有助于减少与一生中多次堕胎相关的放大耻辱感。