Mindus P, Bergström K, Thuomas K A, Hindmarsh T
Department of Phychiatry, Karolinska Sjukhuset, Stockholm, Sweden.
Acta Radiol Suppl. 1986;369:614-7.
Confirmation of radiosurgical lesions in white matter has earlier been difficult to obtain, which has hampered the evaluation of clinical outcome in relation to the site and the size of the lesions. In this investigation 7 consecutive patients subjected to bilateral stereotactic gamma capsulotomy for intractable anxiety disorders were re-examined several years after treatment. The protocol included both magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and computed tomography (CT) interpreted under blind conditions and prospective psychiatric evaluations performed by two independent evaluators who had not been involved in the selection and the treatment of the patients. The lesions were clearly visible with MRI in all patients who improved after treatment. MRI proved to be more accurate than CT both in detecting and in defining the size and the configuration of the lesions. The extent of the tissue reaction following the irradiation seemed to be best defined in T2 weighted images. A high correlation (p less than 0.01) was obtained between ratings of clinical outcome and radiosurgical precision as reflected by MRI. It is concluded that MRI may provide the clinician with more information than CT does. In the future MRI may also facilitate the determination of a radiation threshold value for white and grey matter lesions and provide a more detailed knowledge of the time course of the development of such lesions.
此前一直难以证实白质中的放射外科手术损伤,这妨碍了对与损伤部位和大小相关的临床结果进行评估。在这项研究中,对7例因顽固性焦虑症接受双侧立体定向伽玛囊切开术的患者在治疗数年后进行了复查。方案包括在盲法条件下解读的磁共振成像(MRI)和计算机断层扫描(CT),以及由两名未参与患者选择和治疗的独立评估者进行的前瞻性精神病学评估。在治疗后病情改善的所有患者中,MRI都能清晰显示损伤。事实证明,MRI在检测和确定损伤的大小及形态方面比CT更准确。照射后组织反应的程度似乎在T2加权图像中能得到最佳界定。临床结果评分与MRI所反映的放射外科手术精度之间存在高度相关性(p<0.01)。得出的结论是,MRI可能比CT为临床医生提供更多信息。未来,MRI还可能有助于确定白质和灰质损伤的辐射阈值,并提供关于此类损伤发展时间进程的更详细知识。