RAND, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.
RAND, Santa Monica, California.
J Stud Alcohol Drugs. 2018 May;79(3):399-407. doi: 10.15288/jsad.2018.79.399.
The purpose of this study was to quantify the persistence of immediate changes in adolescents' alcohol-related beliefs associated with exposure to alcohol advertising.
Middle school students (N = 606) carried handheld devices for 14 days and logged all of their exposures to alcohol advertisements as they naturally occurred. Perceptions of the typical person one's age who drinks ("prototype perceptions") and perceived norms regarding alcohol use were assessed after each exposure to advertising and at random prompts issued daily throughout the assessment period. Generalized additive modeling was used to determine how long pro-drinking shifts in beliefs persisted after exposure to advertising.
Following exposure to advertisements, positivity of youth's prototype perceptions immediately increased (β = .07, 95% CI [.06, .09]) and then decreased (β = -.05, 95% CI [-.07, -.03]) over the subsequent 1.5 days, whereas perceived normativeness of alcohol use immediately increased (β = .04, 95% CI [.01, .06]) and then decreased (β = -.03, 95% CI [-.05, -.01]) over the subsequent 2 days. Changes in beliefs occurring after 1.5 days for prototype perceptions and after 2 days for perceived norms were not statistically significant, suggesting that these beliefs were no longer affected by the advertising exposure.
Findings are consistent with theories of alcohol advertising effects that presume that repeated exposure results in cumulative, enduring effects on beliefs. Given the rate of decay of alcohol advertising effects, it may be important to limit youth exposures to one every 2 days to avoid cumulative, lasting pro-drinking shifts in beliefs or to devise ways to interrupt cumulative effects with counter-messaging through media, parents, or other influential others at similar intervals.
本研究旨在量化青少年接触酒类广告后与饮酒相关的信念即刻变化的持久性。
中学生(N=606)携带手持设备 14 天,并记录他们自然接触到的所有酒类广告。在每次接触广告后以及在评估期间每天随机提示时,评估对同龄人饮酒者的典型看法(“原型看法”)和对饮酒行为的感知规范。使用广义加性模型确定在接触广告后,信念中支持饮酒的转变持续多久。
接触广告后,青少年原型看法的积极性即刻增加(β=0.07,95%CI [0.06,0.09]),随后在接下来的 1.5 天内下降(β=-0.05,95%CI [-0.07,-0.03]),而对饮酒行为的感知规范性即刻增加(β=0.04,95%CI [0.01,0.06]),随后在接下来的 2 天内下降(β=-0.03,95%CI [-0.05,-0.01])。原型看法在 1.5 天后和感知规范在 2 天后发生的信念变化不再具有统计学意义,表明这些信念不再受到广告暴露的影响。
研究结果与酒类广告效果的理论一致,即重复接触会导致信念的累积、持久影响。鉴于酒类广告效果的衰减速度,限制青少年每两天接触一次广告以避免信念中持续的、持久的支持饮酒转变,或者设计通过媒体、父母或其他有影响力的人以类似的间隔进行反信息传递以中断累积效应的方法可能很重要。