Bryan Craig J, Griffith James E, Pace Brian T, Hinkson Kent, Bryan AnnaBelle O, Clemans Tracy A, Imel Zac E
The University of Utah, Salt Lake City, UT.
National Center for Veterans Studies, Salt Lake City, UT.
Suicide Life Threat Behav. 2015 Oct;45(5):633-649. doi: 10.1111/sltb.12163. Epub 2015 Apr 8.
Due to seemingly mixed empirical results, questions persist about the possible role of deployments and combat exposure. We conducted a narrative review and meta-analysis of 22 published studies to integrate findings regarding the relationship of deployment-related predictors (i.e., deployment, deployment to a combat zone, combat experience, and exposure to specific combat events) with suicide-related outcomes (i.e., suicide ideation, attempt, and death). Across all predictors and outcomes, the combined effect was small and positive, r = .08 [0.04, 0.13], and marked by significant heterogeneity, I = 99.9%, Q(21)=4880.16, p < .0001, corresponding to a 25% increased risk for suicide-related outcomes among those who have deployed. Studies examining the relationship between exposure to killing and atrocities (k = 5) showed the largest combined effect, r = .12 [0.08, 0.17], and less heterogeneity, I = 84.4%, Q(4)=34.96, p < .0001, corresponding to a 43% increased risk for suicide-related outcomes among those exposed to killing or atrocity. Implications for theory, research, and clinical practice are discussed.
由于实证结果看似参差不齐,关于部署和战斗经历的可能作用仍存在疑问。我们对22项已发表的研究进行了叙述性综述和荟萃分析,以整合有关部署相关预测因素(即部署、部署到战区、战斗经历以及暴露于特定战斗事件)与自杀相关结果(即自杀意念、自杀未遂和自杀死亡)之间关系的研究结果。在所有预测因素和结果中,综合效应较小且呈正向,r = 0.08 [0.04, 0.13],且存在显著异质性,I² = 99.9%,Q(21) = 4880.16,p < 0.0001,这意味着部署人员出现自杀相关结果的风险增加了25%。研究杀人及暴行暴露之间关系的研究(k = 5)显示出最大的综合效应,r = 0.12 [0.08, 0.17],异质性较小,I² = 84.4%,Q(4) = 34.96,p < 0.0001,这意味着暴露于杀人或暴行的人员出现自杀相关结果的风险增加了43%。本文还讨论了对理论、研究和临床实践的启示。