Landriel Federico, Hem Santiago, Rasmussen Jorge, Vecchi Eduardo, Yampolsky Claudio
Departamento de Neurocirugía, Hospital Italiano de Buenos Aires, Argentina.
Surg Neurol Int. 2018 May 10;9(Suppl 2):S43-S49. doi: 10.4103/sni.sni_428_17. eCollection 2018.
The aim of this study was to estimate the learning curve needed for correct placement of minimally invasive percutaneous pedicle screws (PPS).
PPS are the most common system used for instrumentation of spinal lesions that require stabilization.
We retrospectively assessed the insertion of 422 PPS (T5 to S1) in 75 patients operated between 2013-2016 under two-dimensional fluoroscopic guidance. The surgeon 1 always placed the PPS on the right side and the surgeon 2 on the left side. Screw positioning and pedicle rupture was determined with the Gertzbein tomographic classification. We compared the accuracy of PPS placement in our series with a reference rupture rate of 8.08%, value obtained from a meta-analysis.
Of the 422 TTP, 395 were inserted into the pedicle without violation of its cortical wall (Grade 1 = 93.6%), 27 (6.4%) disrupted the pedicle, of which 3.8% were Grade 2, 1.65% Grade 3 and only 0.9% Grade 4. The Surgeon 1, presented an overall break rate of 6.6% reaching standard values of accuracy by placing 74 PPS, Surgeon 2 showed a disruption rate of 6.1%, reaching baseline values at 64 PPS; the difference between them was not statistically significant ( = 0.9009).
In our series, it was necessary to place approximately 70 PPS to achieve intrapedicular accuracy comparable to results reported by experienced surgeons in this minimally invasive technique.
本研究的目的是评估正确置入微创经皮椎弓根螺钉(PPS)所需的学习曲线。
PPS是用于需要稳定的脊柱病变器械固定的最常用系统。
我们回顾性评估了2013年至2016年间在二维透视引导下接受手术的75例患者中422枚PPS(T5至S1)的置入情况。外科医生1总是在右侧置入PPS,外科医生2在左侧置入。采用Gertzbein断层分类法确定螺钉位置和椎弓根破裂情况。我们将本系列中PPS置入的准确性与从荟萃分析中获得的8.08%的参考破裂率进行了比较。
在422枚TTP中,395枚被置入椎弓根且未侵犯其皮质壁(1级=93.6%),27枚(6.4%)破坏了椎弓根,其中3.8%为2级,1.65%为3级,仅0.9%为4级。外科医生1的总体破裂率为6.6%,通过置入74枚PPS达到了标准准确性值,外科医生2的破裂率为6.1%,在置入64枚PPS时达到基线值;两者之间的差异无统计学意义(=0.9009)。
在我们的系列研究中,需要置入约70枚PPS才能达到与该微创技术中经验丰富的外科医生所报告结果相当的椎弓根内准确性。