McHale Timothy S, Chee Wai-Chi, Chan Ka-Chun, Zava David T, Gray Peter B
Department of Anthropology, University of Nevada, 4505 S. Maryland Parkway, Box 455003, Las Vegas, NV, 89154-5003, USA.
Department of Education Studies, Hong Kong Baptist University, Kowloon Tong, Hong Kong.
Hum Nat. 2018 Sep;29(3):245-267. doi: 10.1007/s12110-018-9321-7.
A large body of research links testosterone and cortisol to male-male competition. Yet, little work has explored acute steroid hormone responses to coalitional, physical competition during middle childhood. Here, we investigate testosterone, dehydroepiandrosterone (DHEA), androstenedione, and cortisol release among ethnically Chinese boys in Hong Kong (N = 102), aged 8-11 years, during a soccer match (n = 84) and an intrasquad soccer scrimmage (n = 81), with 63 participants competing in both treatments. The soccer match and intrasquad soccer scrimmage represented out-group and in-group treatments, respectively. Results revealed that testosterone showed no measurable change. DHEA increased during both treatments in the majority of participants and the degree of change had no relation to independent variables (e.g., performance, age, treatment, outcome) or covariate measures (Body Mass Index, Pubertal Development Scale). Most boys experienced androstenedione increases during match play, but no significant differences during the intrasquad soccer scrimmage competitions. The magnitude of change differed significantly between treatments and was positively associated with age. These latter findings suggest boys' androstenedione responses may be sensitive to competitor type (i.e., unknown competitors vs. peers). For most subjects, cortisol significantly increased during match play, decreased during the intrasquad soccer scrimmage, and differed significantly between treatments, suggesting each treatment promoted a different psychological state among competitors. Cortisol/DHEA molar ratio decreased during the intrasquad scrimmage, suggestive of a more relaxed mental state. These data shed new light on potential proximate mechanisms associated with coalitional competition among prepubescent boys, with relevance to adrenarche and life history theory.
大量研究将睾酮和皮质醇与男性之间的竞争联系起来。然而,很少有研究探讨童年中期男孩在联盟性身体竞争中类固醇激素的急性反应。在此,我们调查了香港102名8至11岁的华裔男孩在一场足球比赛(n = 84)和一场队内足球对抗赛(n = 81)中的睾酮、脱氢表雄酮(DHEA)、雄烯二酮和皮质醇释放情况,其中63名参与者参加了这两种比赛。足球比赛和队内足球对抗赛分别代表了组外和组内比赛。结果显示,睾酮没有可测量的变化。大多数参与者在两种比赛中DHEA都有所增加,且变化程度与自变量(如表现、年龄、比赛类型、比赛结果)或协变量指标(体重指数、青春期发育量表)无关。大多数男孩在比赛中雄烯二酮增加,但在队内足球对抗赛中没有显著差异。两种比赛中雄烯二酮变化的幅度差异显著,且与年龄呈正相关。后一项发现表明男孩的雄烯二酮反应可能对竞争对手类型敏感(即未知竞争对手与同龄人)。对于大多数受试者来说,皮质醇在比赛中显著增加,在队内足球对抗赛中减少,且两种比赛之间差异显著,这表明每种比赛在竞争对手中促进了不同的心理状态。队内对抗赛中皮质醇/脱氢表雄酮摩尔比降低,表明心理状态更为放松。这些数据为青春期前男孩联盟竞争的潜在近端机制提供了新的线索,与肾上腺初现和生命史理论相关。