Shaddel Minoo, Sharifi Iraj, Karvar Mehran, Keyhani Alireza, Baziar Zahra
Department of Medical Parasitology and Mycology, School of Medicine, AJA University of Medical Sciences, Tehran; Kerman Leishmaniasis Research Center, Kerman University of Medical Sciences, Kerman, Iran.
Kerman Leishmaniasis Research Center, Kerman University of Medical Sciences, Kerman, Iran.
J Vector Borne Dis. 2018 Jan-Mar;55(1):42-46. doi: 10.4103/0972-9062.234625.
BACKGROUND & OBJECTIVES: Leishmania parasites are sensitive to very low temperature. Cryotherapy is considered as an alternative to the existing pentavalent antimonials, for local treatment of cutaneous leishmaniasis (CL). Normally, liquid nitrogen (N) at a temperature of -196 °C, is used in cryotherapy of CL, but it's efficacy is not consistent. Recently, few studies have also reported the use of carbon dioxide (CO) slush at -78.5 °C in CL cryotherapy. This study was aimed to evaluate the effectiveness of N vs CO cryotherapy for CL treatment in mice. Methods: In total, 21 BALB/c mice were infected with Leishmania major strain [MRHO/IR/74/ER]. Samples were divided into three groups based on the intervention provided-Solid CO cryotherapy, liquid N cryotherapy and control group; with seven mice randomly assigned to each group. Control group received no intervention, and in the other two groups cryotherapy was used every two weeks for maximum of three months. Follow up examinations were scheduled at the time of cryotherapy, during which the size of each lesion was measured. For three mice in each study group, the spleen parasite DNA load was quantified using real-time PCR.
After treatment, the liquid N cryotherapy showed significant reduction in size of the lesions (p = 0.029) as compared to the solid CO cryotherapy and control group. Also, Leishmania DNA load in spleen was significantly lower in the mice receiving liquid N cryotherapy (p <0.001).
INTERPRETATION & CONCLUSION: Liquid N cryotherapy is superior to CO cryotherapy, and it can be an effective method for controlling L. major infection. Further investigations are essential to find optimal number of treatment sessions and time intervals.
利什曼原虫对极低温度敏感。冷冻疗法被认为是现有五价锑剂的替代方法,用于皮肤利什曼病(CL)的局部治疗。通常,-196℃的液氮用于CL的冷冻治疗,但其疗效并不一致。最近,也有少数研究报道在CL冷冻治疗中使用-78.5℃的二氧化碳(CO)雪泥。本研究旨在评估液氮与CO冷冻疗法对小鼠CL治疗的有效性。方法:总共21只BALB/c小鼠感染了硕大利什曼原虫[MRHO/IR/74/ER]株。根据所提供的干预措施将样本分为三组——固体CO冷冻疗法组、液氮冷冻疗法组和对照组;每组随机分配7只小鼠。对照组不接受干预,在其他两组中,每两周进行一次冷冻治疗,最长持续三个月。在冷冻治疗时安排随访检查,期间测量每个病变的大小。对于每个研究组中的三只小鼠,使用实时PCR定量脾脏寄生虫DNA载量。
治疗后,与固体CO冷冻疗法组和对照组相比,液氮冷冻疗法组的病变大小显著减小(p = 0.029)。此外,接受液氮冷冻疗法的小鼠脾脏中的利什曼原虫DNA载量显著更低(p <0.001)。
液氮冷冻疗法优于CO冷冻疗法,它可能是控制硕大利什曼原虫感染的有效方法。进一步研究以确定最佳治疗次数和时间间隔至关重要。