Department of Neurosurgery, University Hospital of Basel, Basel, Switzerland.
PLoS One. 2018 Jun 19;13(6):e0198752. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0198752. eCollection 2018.
Despite being widely used, ventriculoperitoneal (VP) shunt placement is a procedure often associated with complications and revision surgeries. Many neurosurgical centers routinely perform early postoperative cranial computer tomography (CT) to detect postoperative complications (e.g., catheter malposition, postoperative bleed, over-drainage). Because guidelines are lacking, our study aimed to evaluate the yield of early routine postoperative CT after shunt placement for adult hydrocephalus. We retrospectively reviewed 173 patients who underwent frontal VP shunting for various neurosurgical conditions. Radiological outcomes were proximal catheter malposition, and ventricular width in preoperative and postoperative imaging. Clinical outcomes included postoperative neurological outcome, revision surgery because of catheter malposition or other causes, mortality, and finally surgical, non-surgical, and overall morbidity. In only 3 (1.7%) patients did the early routine postoperative CT lead to revision surgery. Diagnostic ratios for CT finding 1 asymptomatic patient who eventually underwent revision surgery per total number to scan were 1:58 for shunt malposition, 1:86 for hygroma, and 1:173 for a cranial bleed. Five (2.9%) patients with clinically asymptomatic shunt malposition or hygroma underwent intervention based on early postoperative CT (diagnostic ratio 1:25). Shunt malposition occurred in no patient with normal pressure hydrocephalus and 2 (40%) patients with stroke. Lower preoperative Evans' Index was a statistically significant predictor for high-grade shunt malposition. We found a rather low yield for early routine postoperative cranial CT after frontal VP-shunt placement. Therefore, careful selection of patients who might benefit, considering the underlying disease and preoperative radiological findings, could reduce unnecessary costs and exposure to radiation.
尽管脑室-腹腔(VP)分流术被广泛应用,但该手术常伴有并发症和再次手术。许多神经外科中心通常会在术后早期进行头颅计算机断层扫描(CT),以检测术后并发症(例如,导管位置不当、术后出血、过度引流)。由于缺乏指南,我们的研究旨在评估成人脑积水 VP 分流术后早期常规行术后 CT 的效果。我们回顾性分析了 173 例因各种神经外科疾病行额部 VP 分流术的患者。影像学结果包括近端导管位置不当和术前、术后脑室宽度。临床结果包括术后神经功能结局、因导管位置不当或其他原因而进行的再次手术、死亡率,以及最终的手术、非手术和总发病率。只有 3 例(1.7%)患者因早期常规术后 CT 而进行了再次手术。因 CT 发现而进行再次手术的无症状患者数量与接受扫描的总人数之比为:导管位置不当 1:58,皮下积液 1:86,颅内出血 1:173。5 例(2.9%)有临床无症状导管位置不当或皮下积液的患者根据早期术后 CT 进行了干预(诊断比为 1:25)。正常压力性脑积水患者无一例发生导管位置不当,脑卒中患者有 2 例(40%)发生。术前 Evans 指数较低是高位导管位置不当的统计学显著预测因素。我们发现,额部 VP 分流术后早期常规行术后颅脑 CT 的效果相当低。因此,考虑到基础疾病和术前影像学发现,对可能受益的患者进行精心选择,可能会降低不必要的成本和辐射暴露。