Samplaski Mary K, Clemesha Chase G
Institute of Urology, University of Southern California, Los Angeles, CA, USA.
Keck School of Medicine, University of Southern California, Los Angeles, CA, USA.
Transl Androl Urol. 2018 May;7(Suppl 2):S193-S197. doi: 10.21037/tau.2018.05.01.
The accuracy of online medical information is variable. A 2014 Cochrane review did not support a robust improvement in male infertility after antioxidant supplementation. Many subfertile men take vitamins in hopes of improving their fertility. We sought to evaluate the content of online information for male fertility vitamins, and compare this with the published literature.
We searched Google to assess online information regarding vitamins and male infertility. Websites were evaluated for authorship, content, claims and validity. We then reviewed the Recommended Daily Allowance and upper tolerable intake level for each vitamin, and compared this with the supplements actual content.
Four websites were posted by an academic source, 7 private clinic, 31 industry, 8 were patient blogs and 50 other sources. Reproductive claims made by websites included: Improved sperm count: 65; improved pregnancy rates: 42; improved live birth rates: 9; healthier offspring: 18. Overall, 76 websites claimed some improvement in semen parameters; 85 claimed some improved reproductive outcome. 26 websites were supported by peer-reviewed literature. None of the supplements had more than the upper tolerable intake level of any of the vitamins, but several were over the RDA, most commonly zinc, vitamin B12 and selenium.
Many websites claim improvements in a variety of male reproductive outcomes after vitamin supplementation. These are often not supported by the medical literature. We need to provide evidence-based information to patients so that they can have realistic expectations of the benefits that vitamins may have on male reproductive outcomes.
在线医学信息的准确性参差不齐。2014年考科蓝协作网的一项综述并不支持补充抗氧化剂后男性不育症有显著改善。许多不育男性服用维生素以期提高生育能力。我们试图评估在线男性生育维生素信息的内容,并将其与已发表的文献进行比较。
我们在谷歌上搜索,以评估有关维生素与男性不育症的在线信息。对网站的作者身份、内容、声明及有效性进行评估。然后我们查阅了每种维生素的推荐每日摄入量和可耐受最高摄入量,并将其与补充剂的实际含量进行比较。
四个网站由学术机构发布,7个来自私人诊所,31个来自行业,8个是患者博客,50个来自其他来源。网站提出的生殖方面的声明包括:精子数量增加:65条;妊娠率提高:42条;活产率提高:9条;后代更健康:18条。总体而言,76个网站称精液参数有一定改善;85个网站称生殖结局有一定改善。26个网站有同行评审文献支持。没有一种补充剂中任何一种维生素的含量超过可耐受最高摄入量,但有几种超过了推荐每日摄入量,最常见的是锌、维生素B12和硒。
许多网站称补充维生素后男性多种生殖结局会得到改善。但这些说法往往没有医学文献的支持。我们需要为患者提供基于证据的信息,以便他们能对维生素可能对男性生殖结局产生的益处有现实的期望。