Hirschmann Nicole, Kastner-Koller Ursula, Deimann Pia, Schmelzer Manuel, Pietschnig Jakob
Faculty of Psychology, Department of Applied Psychology: Health, Development, Enhancement, and Intervention, University of Vienna, Liebiggasse 5, A-1010 Wien, Austria.
J Psychopathol Behav Assess. 2018;40(2):249-258. doi: 10.1007/s10862-017-9630-x. Epub 2017 Nov 4.
When using behavioral-observation methods for coding video footage, it is unknown how much time of an interaction needs to be coded to gain results that are representative for the behavior of interest. The current study examined this problem using the INTAKT, a standardized observational measure for assessing the quality of mother-child interactions. Results from coding only 10 min of each video (i.e., thin slices) were compared with results from coding the remaining parts (averaging about 40 min) of the interaction. Inter-rater agreement for the short versions taken from the beginning or the middle, but not the end of the interactions indicated satisfactory observer accuracy. Coding results did not differ between short and long video sequences, when sequences were taken from the middle of the interactions. Importantly, characteristic differences between different interactive situations were equally well represented in the short and long video sequences. Therefore, our results show that coding only 10 min of an interaction is as reliable and valid as coding full-length videos, if those short sequences are taken from the middle of an interaction. Our findings support the idea that for every method, it is necessary to individually determine the window duration that is long enough to gain results that are reliable and valid.
在使用行为观察方法对视频片段进行编码时,尚不清楚需要对多长时间的互动进行编码才能获得代表感兴趣行为的结果。当前的研究使用INTAKT(一种用于评估母婴互动质量的标准化观察指标)来研究这个问题。将仅对每个视频的10分钟(即薄片)进行编码的结果与对互动的其余部分(平均约40分钟)进行编码的结果进行了比较。从互动开始或中间而非结尾选取的短版本的评分者间一致性表明观察者准确性令人满意。当从互动中间选取序列时,短视频序列和长视频序列的编码结果没有差异。重要的是,不同互动情境之间的特征差异在短视频序列和长视频序列中都得到了同样好的体现。因此,我们的结果表明,如果从互动中间选取那些短序列,那么仅对10分钟的互动进行编码与对全长视频进行编码一样可靠且有效。我们的研究结果支持这样一种观点,即对于每种方法,都有必要单独确定一个足够长的窗口持续时间,以获得可靠且有效的结果。