Clarke L, Abbott H, Sharma P, Eglinton T W, Frizelle F A
Colorectal Unit, Christchurch Hospital Christchurch New Zealand.
Department of Surgery, University of Otago Christchurch New Zealand.
BJS Open. 2018 Mar 15;1(6):202-206. doi: 10.1002/bjs5.34. eCollection 2017 Dec.
Endoscopic stenting is used to palliate malignant large bowel obstruction. A proportion of patients will develop recurrent obstruction due to tumour ingrowth and require reintervention. This study aimed to assess the outcome (clinical success and complication rates) of endoscopic reintervention compared with surgical intervention in patients with stent obstruction due to tumour ingrowth.
This was an observational study using data from a database of patients who underwent palliative colonic stenting between January 1998 and March 2017 at Christchurch Public Hospital.
A total of 190 patients underwent colonic stent insertion, for palliation in 182 cases. Reintervention was performed in 55 (30·2 per cent). Thirty-one patients (17·0 per cent) developed obstruction within the stent at a median of 4·6 (i.q.r. 2·3-7·7) months after the procedure. Of these, 21 had endoscopic restenting and ten underwent surgery. Restenting had technical and clinical success rates of 100 per cent, and involved a significantly shorter length of stay compared with surgery (median 2 (i.q.r. 1-4) versus 11 (6-19) days respectively; P = 0·006). Seven of the 21 patients in the restented group underwent a third palliative intervention. The overall stoma rate in the restented group was significantly lower than that in the surgical group (4 of 21 versus 10 of 10; P < 0·001). There was no difference in complications or survival between the two groups.
Among palliative patients who develop malignant stent obstruction, endoscopic restenting had a high chance of technical success. It resulted in a shorter hospital stay and lower stoma rate than those seen after surgery.
内镜支架置入术用于缓解恶性大肠梗阻。部分患者会因肿瘤向内生长而出现复发性梗阻,需要再次干预。本研究旨在评估因肿瘤向内生长导致支架梗阻的患者,内镜再次干预与手术干预相比的结果(临床成功率和并发症发生率)。
这是一项观察性研究,使用了1998年1月至2017年3月在克赖斯特彻奇公立医院接受姑息性结肠支架置入术患者的数据库数据。
共有190例患者接受了结肠支架置入,其中182例用于缓解症状。55例(30.2%)患者接受了再次干预。31例患者(17.0%)在术后中位时间4.6(四分位间距2.3 - 7.7)个月时出现支架内梗阻。其中,21例接受了内镜再次支架置入,10例接受了手术。再次支架置入的技术成功率和临床成功率均为100%,与手术相比住院时间显著缩短(分别为中位2(四分位间距1 - 4)天和11(6 - 19)天;P = 0.006)。再次支架置入组的21例患者中有7例接受了第三次姑息性干预。再次支架置入组的总体造口率显著低于手术组(21例中的4例与10例中的10例;P < 0.001)。两组在并发症或生存率方面无差异。
在出现恶性支架梗阻的姑息性患者中,内镜再次支架置入术技术成功的可能性很高。与手术后相比,其住院时间更短,造口率更低。