Department of Otolaryngology, Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts.
Department of Otolaryngology, Massachusetts Eye and Ear Infirmary, Boston, Massachusetts.
Clin Otolaryngol. 2018 Oct;43(5):1328-1334. doi: 10.1111/coa.13177. Epub 2018 Jul 26.
To determine the minimal clinically important difference (MCID) of the 22-item Sinonasal Outcome Test (SNOT-22) in individuals undergoing medical management for their chronic rhinosinusitis (CRS).
Prospective observational study.
Academic, tertiary care centre.
A total of 247 adults undergoing medical management for CRS.
At enrolment, participants completed a SNOT-22. At a subsequent follow-up visit, 2-12 months after enrolment, participants also completed a SNOT-22. At follow-up, participants also rated the change in their sinus symptoms and general health as "Much worse," "A little worse," "About the same," "A little better" or "Much better" compared with enrolment; these two questions were used as sinus symptom and general health anchor questions, respectively. The SNOT-22 MCID was calculated using distribution-based, anchor-based and receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve-based methods.
Using the distribution-based method, the SNOT-22 MCID was 11.6. Using the sinus symptom anchor question, the SNOT-22 MCID was 10.5; applying the ROC method to the sinus symptom anchor yielded an MCID of 12.5. In comparison, using the general health anchor question, the SNOT-22 MCID was 8.3; applying the ROC method to the sinus symptom anchor yielded an MCID of 17.5. In all cases, the calculated MCID had a sensitivity of approximately 50-60% and specificity of approximately 80-90%.
Based on our results, we propose a SNOT-22 MCID of 12 in medically managed patients with CRS. The MCID, while specific, was not sensitive for identifying patients with CRS experiencing a noticeable improvement in sinus symptoms or general health.
确定接受慢性鼻-鼻窦炎(CRS)药物治疗的患者中 22 项鼻鼻窦结局测试(SNOT-22)的最小临床重要差异(MCID)。
前瞻性观察性研究。
学术性三级护理中心。
共 247 名接受 CRS 药物治疗的成年人。
在入组时,患者完成 SNOT-22 量表。在随后的随访中,即入组后 2-12 个月,患者也完成 SNOT-22 量表。在随访时,患者还将其鼻窦症状和总体健康的变化与入组时相比评为“差很多”“稍差”“差不多”“稍好”或“好很多”;这两个问题分别作为鼻窦症状和总体健康锚定问题。使用基于分布的、基于锚定的和基于接收者操作特征(ROC)曲线的方法计算 SNOT-22 MCID。
使用基于分布的方法,SNOT-22 MCID 为 11.6。使用基于鼻窦症状的锚定问题,SNOT-22 MCID 为 10.5;将 ROC 方法应用于鼻窦症状锚定问题,得到的 MCID 为 12.5。相比之下,使用基于总体健康的锚定问题,SNOT-22 MCID 为 8.3;将 ROC 方法应用于鼻窦症状锚定问题,得到的 MCID 为 17.5。在所有情况下,计算的 MCID 的敏感性约为 50%-60%,特异性约为 80%-90%。
基于我们的结果,我们提出了在接受 CRS 药物治疗的患者中 SNOT-22 MCID 为 12 的建议。该 MCID 虽然具有特异性,但对识别 CRS 患者的鼻窦症状或总体健康有明显改善的情况并不敏感。