Butler Barbara A, Ford Robert G
U.S. EPA Office of Research and Development, National Risk Management Research Laboratory, Cincinnati, OH 45268.
Mine Water Environ. 2018 Mar 31;37(1):18-30. doi: 10.1007/s10230-017-0484-y.
Measurement of total suspended solids (TSS) and total dissolved solids (TDS) loadings in streams is often used to assess potential impacts from mining on surface water quality within a drainage basin. It has been suggested that TSS could be used as an indicator to estimate TDS loading through the use of a TDS/TSS ratio. The reliability of this approach was tested by examining empirical linear relationships between TSS and TDS loads at three locations within a mining-influenced watershed in Colorado. Predictive accuracy of the relationships was assessed using an independent source of data for the same locations, with comparisons between estimated and observed TDS loads for periods within and outside the years used to develop relationships. Evaluations were conducted over the entire flow regime and for separate periods of low- and high-flow. Improved representation of the data was achieved by incorporation of a regressed average baseflow contribution, indicating the relationship between TDS and TSS loads is not accurately represented by a simple ratio. High variability in data between locations prevents application of a basin scale relationship to all locations within that basin. Local-scale relationships developed under specific flow regimes resulted in more accurate predictions, but results suggest that factors additional to flow may need to be considered to improve predictability. Usefulness of linear empirical relationships to predict TDS load from TSS load will depend on the magnitude of uncertainty that is tolerable for a given situation.
测量溪流中的总悬浮固体(TSS)和总溶解固体(TDS)负荷通常用于评估采矿对流域内地表水水质的潜在影响。有人提出,通过使用TDS/TSS比率,TSS可作为估算TDS负荷的指标。通过研究科罗拉多州一个受采矿影响的流域内三个地点的TSS和TDS负荷之间的经验线性关系,对该方法的可靠性进行了测试。使用相同地点的独立数据源评估这些关系的预测准确性,并比较用于建立关系的年份内和年份外各时期估计的和观测到的TDS负荷。在整个水流状态以及低流量和高流量的不同时期进行了评估。通过纳入回归平均基流贡献,数据得到了更好的呈现,这表明TDS和TSS负荷之间的关系不能用简单的比率准确表示。不同地点的数据高度可变,这使得无法将流域尺度的关系应用于该流域内的所有地点。在特定水流状态下建立的局部尺度关系产生了更准确的预测,但结果表明,可能需要考虑流量以外的因素来提高可预测性。利用线性经验关系从TSS负荷预测TDS负荷将取决于给定情况下可容忍的不确定性程度。