Webster Kyle D, Michalowski Susan, Hranilovich Thomas E
College of Osteopathic Medicine, Michigan State University, East Lansing, MI, United States.
Psychiatric Associates, Okemos, MI, United States.
Front Psychiatry. 2018 Jun 21;9:275. doi: 10.3389/fpsyt.2018.00275. eCollection 2018.
The legitimacy and etiology of Dissociative Identity Disorder (DID) remains a controversial topic within Psychiatry. The two schools of thought are the Post-Traumatic Model (PTM) and the Socio-Cognitive Model (SCM). This case highlights the validity of PTM in an individual who suffered severe and prolonged physical, psychological, and sexual abuse from 2 years old through adulthood. The reported abuse was corroborated and proven on two separate occasions via medical professionals/rape kit and the police. This resulted in the incarceration of one of her abusers. The only way for the patient to cope with the trauma she suffered was to dissociate, which resulted in the development of four full identity alters. In addition to being diagnosed with DID, the patient has been diagnosed with Major Depressive Disorder (MDD), Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD), and chronic suicidality. Unable to manage the suicidal ideations and MDD after nearly 10 years of therapy and psychiatric medications, the patient was referred for Electroconvulsive Therapy (ECT). Upon receiving ECT weekly for 2 years, the patient reported having "lost the others." As ECT progressed she went from having four alters to no alters and at the time of this report only being able to vaguely hear alter #4. With the integration of these alters she had access to the memories and pain that the alters had protected her from. Prior to losing the alters, her long-term memory was impaired by dissociative processes. Her long-term memory was also impaired because when one of the alters was in control of consciousness only that alter remembered what had happened during that time, unless that alter shared what had happened with one or more of the others. It is unclear if frequent ECT was the catalyst that lead to the integration of her alters however, integration finally began following prolonged ECT. This case highlights the importance of the PTM as an etiological description for DID and the importance of mental health providers further studying and researching the effects of ECT on patients with chronic MDD, PTSD, and suicidal intent, especially if these are comorbid with DID.
分离性身份障碍(DID)的合理性及病因在精神病学领域仍是一个有争议的话题。两种主要观点是创伤后模型(PTM)和社会认知模型(SCM)。本病例突出了PTM在一名从2岁到成年遭受严重且长期身体、心理和性虐待个体中的有效性。所报告的虐待情况经医疗专业人员/强奸案证据采集工具及警方在两个不同场合得到证实。这导致其中一名施虐者被监禁。患者应对所遭受创伤的唯一方式是解离,这导致了四个完整的身份转变。除了被诊断为DID外,患者还被诊断患有重度抑郁症(MDD)、创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)以及慢性自杀倾向。经过近10年的治疗和精神科药物治疗后,患者仍无法控制自杀意念和MDD,遂被转介接受电休克治疗(ECT)。在接受了为期2年的每周一次ECT治疗后,患者报告称“失去了其他身份”。随着ECT治疗的推进,她从有四个身份转变到没有身份转变,在撰写本报告时,只能模糊地听到身份4的声音。随着这些身份转变的整合,她能够接触到那些身份曾保护她免受的记忆和痛苦。在失去这些身份转变之前,她的长期记忆因解离过程而受损。她的长期记忆受损还因为当其中一个身份控制意识时,只有那个身份记得那段时间发生的事情,除非那个身份与其他一个或多个身份分享所发生的事情。目前尚不清楚频繁的ECT是否是导致她身份转变整合的催化剂,然而,在长期ECT治疗后整合最终开始。本病例突出了PTM作为DID病因描述的重要性,以及心理健康提供者进一步研究ECT对患有慢性MDD、PTSD和自杀意图患者影响的重要性,特别是当这些疾病与DID共病时。