Mitkov Mario V, Thomas Colleen S, Cochuyt Jordan J, Forte Antonio J, Perdikis Galen
Department of Dermatology, Mayo Clinic, Jacksonville, FL.
Division of Biomedical Statistics and Informatics, Mayo Clinic, Jacksonville, FL.
Aesthet Surg J. 2018 Nov 12;38(12):NP207-NP212. doi: 10.1093/asj/sjy159.
Learning to inject botulinum toxin for cosmetic purposes is difficult for beginners, given the nature of the procedure and patient population. Simulation training is an effective modality for medical professionals to acquire skills in an environment that provides low stress and ample opportunity for questions and correction of mistakes.
Compare posttraining comfort, knowledge, and practical botulinum toxin injection scores among trainees who underwent simulation vs video training only.
A total of 20 nurse practitioners, physician assistants, and resident physicians underwent cosmetic botulinum toxin injection training either through lecture and video, or lecture and hands-on simulation training. Comfort, knowledge, and practical test scores were recorded and compared between the groups.
There was no evidence of a statistically significant difference in comfort or knowledge scores between simulation and video groups. The median (range) practical score was significantly higher in the simulation group compared to the video group (59.0 [31-60] vs 44.5 [27-57]; P < 0.01).
Despite feeling similarly comfortable and having similar written knowledge test scores, the trainees who underwent simulation training had significantly higher hands-on practical test scores compared to trainees who underwent video training only for cosmetic botulinum toxin injections.
鉴于肉毒杆菌毒素注射美容操作的性质和患者群体情况,对于初学者而言,学习进行此类注射操作颇具难度。模拟训练是一种有效的方式,能让医学专业人员在压力较小且有大量机会提问和纠正错误的环境中掌握技能。
比较仅接受视频训练的学员与接受模拟训练的学员在训练后的舒适度、知识掌握情况以及肉毒杆菌毒素实际注射操作得分。
共有20名执业护士、医师助理和住院医师,他们要么通过讲座和视频,要么通过讲座和实际模拟训练接受肉毒杆菌毒素美容注射培训。记录并比较两组学员的舒适度、知识掌握情况和实际操作测试得分。
模拟组和视频组在舒适度或知识得分方面,均无统计学上的显著差异证据。模拟组的实际操作得分中位数(范围)显著高于视频组(59.0 [31 - 60] 对比 44.5 [27 - 57];P < 0.01)。
尽管接受模拟训练和仅接受视频训练的学员在舒适度感受和书面知识测试得分方面相近,但在肉毒杆菌毒素美容注射的实际操作测试中,接受模拟训练的学员得分显著高于仅接受视频训练的学员。