Widdows Heather, MacCallum Fiona
Department of Philosophy, University of Birmingham, Edgbaston, Birmingham, B15 2TT, UK.
Department of Psychology, University of Warwick, Coventry, CV4 7AL, UK.
Health Care Anal. 2018 Sep;26(3):207-219. doi: 10.1007/s10728-018-0360-3.
This article introduces a Special Issue comprising four papers emerging from the Beauty Demands Network project, and maps key issues in the beauty debate. The introduction first discusses the purpose of the Network; to consider the changing demands of beauty across disciplines and beyond academia. It then summarises the findings of the Network workshops, emphasising the complex place of notions of normality, and the different meanings and functions attached to 'normal' in the beauty context. Concerns are raised here about the use of normal to justify and motivate engaging in beauty practices such as cosmetic surgery and 'non-invasive' procedures. Other workshop findings included the recognition of beauty as increasingly a global value rather than a culturally distinct ideal, and the understanding that there is no clear distinction between beauty practices that are considered standard and those that are considered extreme. These themes, especially the concerns around understanding of normal, are reflected in the recommendations made by the Network in its Briefing Paper, which are presented next in this introduction. A further theme picked up by these recommendations is the extent to which individuals who are not traditionally vulnerable may be so in the beauty context. Finally, the introduction highlights the key matters covered in the four papers of the Special Issue: regulatory concerns around cosmetic surgery tourism; the impact of digitally altered images from psychological and philosophical perspectives; the ethics of genetic selection for fair skin; and the attraction and beauty of the contemporary athletic body.
本文介绍了一个特刊,其中包含四篇源自“美丽需求网络”项目的论文,并梳理了美丽议题中的关键问题。引言部分首先讨论了该网络的目的:考量跨学科及学术界之外不断变化的美丽需求。接着总结了网络研讨会的成果,强调了常态概念的复杂地位,以及在美丽语境中赋予“正常”的不同含义和功能。此处对用正常来为诸如整容手术和“非侵入性”程序等美丽行为辩护及提供动力的做法提出了担忧。研讨会的其他成果包括认识到美丽日益成为一种全球价值观,而非一种具有文化独特性的理想,以及理解被视为标准的美丽行为和被视为极端的美丽行为之间并无明显区别。这些主题,尤其是围绕对正常的理解的担忧,反映在该网络在其简报文件中提出的建议中,这些建议将在本引言的下文中呈现。这些建议所涉及的另一个主题是,在美丽语境中,那些传统上不脆弱的人可能会变得脆弱的程度。最后,引言突出了特刊四篇论文所涵盖的关键问题:整容手术旅游的监管问题;从心理学和哲学角度看数字修改图像的影响;白皙皮肤基因选择的伦理问题;以及当代运动员身体的吸引力和美感。