Bahnmueller Julia, Nuerk Hans-Christoph, Moeller Korbinian
Neuro-cognitive Plasticity Laboratory, Leibniz-Institut für Wissensmedien, Tübingen, Germany.
Department of Psychology, Eberhard Karls University of Tübingen, Tübingen, Germany.
Front Psychol. 2018 Jun 25;9:1024. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2018.01024. eCollection 2018.
Research on associations between language and number processing has seen growing interest in the last years - in particular with respect to place-value processing in multi-digit numbers. Recently, Dowker and Nuerk (2016) proposed a taxonomy of linguistic influences on number processing. However, this taxonomy does not address the generality or specificity of linguistic influences across different levels of number processing. In contrast, Nuerk et al. (2015) proposed different levels of place-value processing in multi-digit numbers. However, the authors did not specify if and how linguistic factors influence these levels of place-value processing. The present perspective aims at addressing this conceptual gap by suggesting an integrated taxonomy representing how different linguistic factors may influence different levels of place-value processing. We show that some effects of different linguistic levels have already been observed on different levels of place-value processing. Moreover, while some linguistic influences (e.g., lexical influences) have been studied for all levels of place-value processing, other influences have been studied for only one level or even none. Beyond categorizing existing research, we argue that the explicit consideration of research gaps may inspire new research paradigms complementing the picture of language influences on place-value processing. We conclude by outlining the importance of a differential approach for levels of both linguistic and number processing to evaluate linguistic obstacles and facilitators of different languages and their relevance for numerical development.
近年来,关于语言与数字加工之间关联的研究越来越受到关注,尤其是在多位数的位值加工方面。最近,道克和努尔克(2016年)提出了一种关于语言对数字加工影响的分类法。然而,这种分类法并未涉及语言影响在不同数字加工水平上的普遍性或特殊性。相比之下,努尔克等人(2015年)提出了多位数中不同的位值加工水平。然而,作者并未具体说明语言因素是否以及如何影响这些位值加工水平。本观点旨在通过提出一种综合分类法来填补这一概念空白,该分类法展示了不同语言因素可能如何影响不同水平的位值加工。我们表明,已经在不同水平的位值加工上观察到了不同语言水平的一些影响。此外,虽然一些语言影响(如词汇影响)已针对所有位值加工水平进行了研究,但其他影响仅针对一个水平进行了研究,甚至有些影响尚未被研究。除了对现有研究进行分类外,我们认为明确考虑研究空白可能会激发新的研究范式,以完善语言对位值加工影响的图景。我们最后概述了一种针对语言和数字加工水平的差异方法对于评估不同语言的语言障碍和促进因素及其与数字发展相关性的重要性。