Department of Nutrition, Dietetics and Food, Monash University, Notting Hill, Victoria, Australia.
School of Public Health, Curtin University, Bentley, Western Australia, Australia.
Nutr Diet. 2018 Jul;75(3):307-315. doi: 10.1111/1747-0080.12359. Epub 2017 Jun 19.
Competency standards are widely adopted as a framework to describe standards of performance required in the workplace. Little is known, however, about how students construct competence. This qualitative study aimed to explore how dietetics students ready to graduate construct the concept of competence and the role of assessment in developing professional competence.
A qualitative description was used to gather data from a convenience sample of students ready to graduate from universities with accredited dietetics programs across Australia (10 out of 15 at the time of the study). A total of 11 focus groups were conducted to explore perspectives of competence and experiences of 'competency-based' assessment. Data were audio-recorded, transcribed and analysed using a thematic analysis approach.
A total of 81 (n = 81) participants across 10 universities representing 22% of total students participated in the focus groups. Themes revealed that: (i) there is no shared understanding of competence; (ii) current work placement experiences may not reflect current standards or workforce needs; (iii) assessment approaches may not fully support the development of competence; and (iv) the competent performance of supervising dietitians/clinical educators in the workplace influences the construction of competence.
There is a need to work towards a shared understanding of dietetic entry-level competence in the profession. 'Work-based' learning experiences may need to be modified to ensure students meet current competency standards. Practitioners involved in student supervision need to acknowledge the influential role they have in the development of the future workforce.
能力标准被广泛用作描述工作场所所需绩效标准的框架。然而,对于学生如何构建能力,人们知之甚少。这项定性研究旨在探讨即将毕业的营养学学生如何构建能力概念以及评估在培养专业能力中的作用。
采用定性描述方法,从澳大利亚具有认证营养学项目的大学中随机抽取即将毕业的学生(研究时共有 15 名学生中的 10 名)进行数据收集。共进行了 11 次焦点小组讨论,以探讨对能力的看法以及“基于能力”评估的经验。使用主题分析方法对音频记录、转录和分析数据。
共有来自 10 所大学的 81 名(n=81)参与者代表了总学生的 22%,参加了焦点小组讨论。主题揭示了:(i)对能力没有共同的理解;(ii)当前的工作实习经验可能无法反映当前的标准或劳动力需求;(iii)评估方法可能无法完全支持能力的发展;以及(iv)工作场所中监督营养师/临床教育者的胜任表现会影响能力的构建。
需要努力在该行业内达成对营养学入门级能力的共识。“基于工作”的学习经验可能需要进行修改,以确保学生达到当前的能力标准。参与学生监督的从业者需要承认他们在培养未来劳动力方面的影响力。