The Impact of Simulator Size on Forces Generated in the Performance of a Defined Intracorporeal Suturing Task: A Pilot Study.

In pediatric minimal access surgery, the operative domain may vary from that of an adult to that of a neonate. This study aimed to quantify the impact of decreased operative domain on forces generated in the performance of a defined intracorporeal suturing task. One hundred five participants performed a defined intracorporeal suturing task in small and large simulators. Time to task completion and force analysis parameters (FAPs = total, maximum, and mean forces in , and axes) were measured. Expertise level was assigned based on the number of laparoscopic cases. Outcomes were analyzed using paired sample -tests, value of <.05. Time to task completion varied significantly for experts between adult and pediatric simulators but not for intermediates or novices. Total, maximum, and mean forces in the ("side to side") axis were significantly greater in the larger laparoscopic simulator for all levels of expertise. In the axis ("in and out" movement) and axis ("up and down" movement), total and mean forces were higher in the adult simulator regardless of the level of expertise. Differences in maximum force between the adult and pediatric simulators in the axis ("up and down" movement) varied significantly for novices and intermediates but not for experts. Forces were greater, particularly in the side-to-side plane, in the larger simulator for participants of all levels in the performance of this defined intracorporeal suturing task. Further analysis will determine the reasons for and implications of the increased force parameters in the simulator of larger domain.