Experts in Minimally Invasive Surgery are Outperformed by Trained Novices on Suturing Skills.

INTRODUCTION

Learning minimally invasive suturing can be challenging, creating a barrier to further implementation, especially with the development of easier methods. Nevertheless, mastering intracorporeal knot tying is crucial when alternative techniques prove inadequate. Therefore, the minimally invasive surgery (MIS) suturing skills of MIS experts are compared with a group of novices during their learning curve on a simulator.

METHODS

The novice participants repeatedly performed the intracorporeal suturing task on the EoSim MIS simulator (up to a maximum of 20 repetitions). The experts (>50 MIS procedures and advanced MIS experience) completed the same task once. The first and last exercises of the novices and the expert tasks were all blindly recorded and assessed by two independent assessors using the Laparoscopic Suturing Competency Assessment Tool (LS-CAT). Additionally, objective assessment parameters, "time" and "distance", using instrument tracking, were collected. The scores of the experts were then compared with the novices.

RESULTS

At the end of the training, novices significantly outperformed the experts on both the expert assessment (LS-CAT: 16.8 versus 26.8, P = 0.001) and objective parameters (median time: 190 s versus 161 s, P < 0.001; median distance: 6.1 m versus 3.6 m, P < 0.001). Although the experts showed slightly better performance than the novices during their first task, the difference was not significant on the expert assessment (LS-CAT experts 16.8, novices 20.5, P = 0.057).

CONCLUSIONS

Our findings underscore the significance of continued MIS suturing training for both residents and surgeons. In this study, trained novices demonstrated a significant outperformance of experts on both quantitative and qualitative outcome parameters within a simulated setting.