Alqassas Maryam A, Muthaffar Osama Y, Aljawi Anan A, Taj Ahad M, Nijaifan Haya K, Alyoubi Reem A, Jan Mohammed M
Departments of Pediatrics, King Abdulaziz University, Jeddah, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia.
Neurosciences (Riyadh). 2018 Jul;23(3):258-261. doi: 10.17712/nsj.2018.3.20180015.
To evaluate the treatment approach and compliance of pediatric neurologists with evidence-based guidelines across Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (KSA). These guidelines that clarify the optimal management of infantile spasms (IS) are not widely followed for various practical reasons.
Physicians practicing in the field of pediatric neurology in KSA were contacted from the database of national societies. A cross-sectional study was conducted using a structured 20-item on-line survey designed to examine their clinical experience with IS and their treatment choices.
A total of 52 pediatric neurologists completed the survey (69% estimated capture rate). They received their formal training within KSA (40%), North America (33%), or Europe (14%). The majority practiced in 2 major cities, Riyadh (46%) or Jeddah (19%). Vigabatrin was favored over adrenocorticotropic hormone (ACTH) as first line drug for patients without tuberous sclerosis complex (48% vs. 21%). Several factors correlated with correctly selecting ACTH as first line including western training (33% vs. 5%, p=0.001), practicing in the city of Riyadh (25% vs. 14%, p=0.001), or having >10 years of clinical experience (25% vs. 5%, p=0.017). Reasons for not complying with the recommended treatment guidelines included lack of availability of ACTH (42%), side effect profile of steroids (29%), and personal preferences (14%). Only 4% admitted lack of awareness of the currently published management guidelines.
Many pediatric neurologists in KSA are not following the published IS management guidelines. Using ACTH as first line correlated with their training, practice location, and years of experience. Lack of drug availability and side effect profile were common reasons for not complying with the management guidelines.
评估沙特阿拉伯王国(KSA)儿科神经科医生对循证指南的治疗方法及依从性。这些阐明婴儿痉挛症(IS)最佳管理方法的指南因各种实际原因未得到广泛遵循。
从全国性学会数据库联系了在KSA从事儿科神经学领域工作的医生。采用一项包含20项内容的结构化在线调查进行横断面研究,旨在调查他们对IS的临床经验及其治疗选择。
共有52名儿科神经科医生完成了调查(估计捕获率为69%)。他们在KSA(40%)、北美(33%)或欧洲(14%)接受正规培训。大多数人在两个主要城市执业,利雅得(46%)或吉达(19%)。对于无结节性硬化症的患者,作为一线药物,氨己烯酸比促肾上腺皮质激素(ACTH)更受青睐(48%对21%)。与正确选择ACTH作为一线药物相关的几个因素包括西式培训(33%对5%,p = 0.001)、在利雅得市执业(25%对14%,p = 0.001)或有超过10年临床经验(25%对5%,p = 0.017)。不遵循推荐治疗指南的原因包括ACTH无法获取(42%)、类固醇的副作用(29%)和个人偏好(14%)。只有4%的人承认对当前已发表的管理指南缺乏认识。
KSA的许多儿科神经科医生未遵循已发表的IS管理指南。将ACTH用作一线药物与他们的培训、执业地点和经验年限相关。药物无法获取和副作用是不遵循管理指南的常见原因。