Department of Anesthesiology, Intensive Care and Burns Unit, University Hospital Saint Louis-Lariboisière, Assistance Publique-Hôpitaux de Paris, Paris, France.
LMS, Ecole Polytechnique, CNRS, Université Paris-Saclay, Palaiseau, France.
Shock. 2019 May;51(5):585-592. doi: 10.1097/SHK.0000000000001216.
In shock, the increase in cutaneous-to-arterial carbon dioxide partial pressure (Pc-aCO2) and the decrease in the perfusion index (PI) are related to macrovascular or microvascular alterations. We hypothesized that inducing cutaneous vasodilation and local perfusion with heat could provide a noninvasive tool to monitor microvascular reactivity.
This study aimed to develop a noninvasive approach, the heating challenge (HC), to monitor the microvascular reactivity of patients with shock and to evaluate the potential relationship with outcome.
After ethics committee agreement was obtained, 59 shock patients, including 37 septic shock, 22 non-septic shock (14 cardiogenic and eight hemorrhagic), 10 intensive care unit (ICU)-controls and 12 healthy volunteers, were included in this study. The HC consisted of heating the ear lobe PcCO2 sensor from 37° to 45° over 5 min and recording PcCO2 and PI variations (ΔPcCO2 and PImax/min). HC was performed on admission and during the first 48 h of hospitalization.
Pc-aCO2 was significantly higher in shock patients than ICU-controls at baseline (P < 0.05). HC led to a decrease in PcCO2 and an increase in PI in the healthy volunteers (ΔPcCO2 = -9.0 ± 4.6% and PImax/min = 5.5 ± 1.9). On admission, non-septic shock patients (cardiogenic and hemorrhagic shocks) had an HC response profile identical to that of healthy volunteers and ICU-controls. In contrast, septic shock patients had a lower ΔPcCO 2 and PImax/min compared to healthy volunteers and all other groups (P < 0.05). After the first day, the combination of a Pc-aCO2 >17 mm Hg with a positive ΔPcCO2 could predict mortality with a specificity of 82% and a sensitivity of 93%.
HC appears to be a dynamic test to classify vascular reactivity alterations in shock. At baseline, HC results were impaired in septic patients and conserved in non-septic patients. After the first day, the association between Pc-aCO2 and ΔPcCO2 was strongly related to prognosis in shock patients.
在休克状态下,皮肤与动脉间二氧化碳分压差(Pc-aCO2)的增加和灌注指数(PI)的降低与大血管或微血管改变有关。我们假设通过热刺激诱导皮肤血管扩张和局部灌注,可以提供一种监测微血管反应性的非侵入性工具。
本研究旨在开发一种非侵入性方法——加热挑战(HC),以监测休克患者的微血管反应性,并评估其与预后的潜在关系。
在获得伦理委员会的同意后,纳入了 59 例休克患者,包括 37 例脓毒症休克、22 例非脓毒症休克(14 例心源性休克和 8 例出血性休克)、10 例重症监护病房(ICU)对照组和 12 例健康志愿者。HC 包括将耳廊 PcCO2 传感器从 37℃加热至 45℃,持续 5min,并记录 PcCO2 和 PI 的变化(ΔPcCO2 和 PImax/min)。HC 在入院时和住院的前 48h 内进行。
休克患者的 Pc-aCO2 基线值明显高于 ICU 对照组(P<0.05)。HC 导致健康志愿者的 PcCO2 降低和 PI 增加(ΔPcCO2=-9.0±4.6%和 PImax/min=5.5±1.9)。入院时,非脓毒症休克患者(心源性和出血性休克)的 HC 反应模式与健康志愿者和 ICU 对照组相同。相比之下,脓毒症休克患者的ΔPcCO2 和 PImax/min 明显低于健康志愿者和所有其他组(P<0.05)。入院后第 1 天,Pc-aCO2>17mmHg 合并ΔPcCO2阳性可预测死亡率,特异性为 82%,敏感性为 93%。
HC 似乎是一种用于分类休克血管反应改变的动态试验。在基线时,HC 结果在脓毒症患者中受损,而非脓毒症患者中则保持正常。入院后第 1 天,Pc-aCO2 与ΔPcCO2 之间的相关性与休克患者的预后密切相关。