Barkhuff Daniel, Nitta Carlos H, Cobb Robert, Ernst Amy A, Weiss Steven J
From the Department of Emergency Medicine, University of New Mexico, Albuquerque.
South Med J. 2018 Aug;111(8):489-493. doi: 10.14423/SMJ.0000000000000849.
Cellulitis is a leading cause of emergency department (ED) visits, with more than 200 cases per 100,000 people per year. Although many risk factors have been identified, including edema, skin breakdown, and penetrance of the skin, there are few data available on whether personal hygiene habits (bathing and clean clothes) are associated with increased risk for soft tissue infection. Studies looking at chlorhexidine baths in the intensive care unit to prevent soft tissue infections have shown conflicting and limited efficacy. Our objective was to determine whether poor personal hygiene, as manifested in poor bathing habits, a lack of access to clean clothes, or frequent needle self-injections, are associated with cellulitis or abscesses.
The research is a cross-sectional cohort study of patients with either cellulitis, soft tissue abscess, or both (cases) versus a control group of patients with abdominal pain without prior surgeries in a large, urban ED in a convenience sampling. We asked about bathing habits, access to clean clothing, and skin breaks from intravenous (IV) drug use as risk factors. The two groups were compared using descriptive statistics, and a regression analysis was performed to determine the characteristics that are predictive of soft tissue infections. The study was powered at 0.8 to detect a 20% difference in adequate bathing habits with 100 per group.
In an approximate 1-year study period, 108 cases were identified and compared with 104 abdominal pain controls selected at random from patients presenting to the same ED. In the cellulitis/abscess group the mean age was 47 and 81% were men, and in the control group the mean age was 45 and 39% were men. There were significantly more men in the cellulitis/abscess group (Diff 22%, 95% confidence interval [CI] 8-34, < 0.01). Seventy percent (76 of 108) of cases versus 58% (80 of 104) of controls bathed daily (odds ratio [OR] 1.7, 95% CI 0.98-3.1, not significant). There was a significant difference between the two groups in laundry habits: 66% (71 of 108) of cases versus 42% (44 of 104) of controls did not have access to clean laundry daily (adjusted OR [AOR] 2.5, 95% CI 1.4-5.0, < 0.01). The most profound and significant difference was noted between cases and controls regarding the use of IV drugs, in which 20 of 108 cases (19%) used IV drugs versus 3 of 104 controls (3%, < 0.01). Finally, 35 of 108 (32%) of our cases had a history of infections, whereas only 5 of 104 (5%) of the controls had cellulitis or an abscess previously ( < 0.01). On regression analysis significant predictors of soft tissue infection were history of skin infection (AOR 7.0) and not cleaning clothes daily (AOR 2.5).
There was no significant difference in bathing habits, but there was a significant difference in laundry habits between the case and control groups. Our study further confirms that IV drug use is a risk factor for cellulitis and no access to clean clothes daily was significantly related to the development of cellulitis. Failing to obtain daily showers was not associated with an increase in infection.
蜂窝织炎是急诊科就诊的主要原因,每年每10万人中有超过200例。虽然已确定许多风险因素,包括水肿、皮肤破损和皮肤穿透,但关于个人卫生习惯(洗澡和穿干净衣服)是否与软组织感染风险增加相关的数据很少。研究重症监护病房使用洗必泰浴预防软组织感染的效果存在矛盾且有限。我们的目的是确定个人卫生差,如洗澡习惯不良、无法获得干净衣服或频繁自我注射针头,是否与蜂窝织炎或脓肿有关。
该研究是一项横断面队列研究,将患有蜂窝织炎、软组织脓肿或两者皆有的患者(病例组)与在一家大型城市急诊科方便抽样选取的无既往手术史的腹痛对照组患者进行比较。我们询问了洗澡习惯、获得干净衣服的情况以及静脉注射吸毒导致的皮肤破损作为风险因素。使用描述性统计对两组进行比较,并进行回归分析以确定预测软组织感染的特征。该研究的检验效能为0.8,以检测每组100人时在充分洗澡习惯方面20%的差异。
在大约1年的研究期间,确定了108例病例,并与从同一急诊科就诊患者中随机选取的104例腹痛对照组进行比较。蜂窝织炎/脓肿组的平均年龄为47岁,男性占81%,对照组的平均年龄为45岁,男性占39%。蜂窝织炎/脓肿组的男性明显更多(差异22%,95%置信区间[CI]8 - 34,P < 0.01)。70%(108例中的76例)的病例组与58%(104例中的80例)的对照组每天洗澡(比值比[OR]1.7,95%CI 0.98 - 3.1,无显著性)。两组在洗衣习惯上存在显著差异:66%(108例中的71例)的病例组与42%(104例中的44例)的对照组无法每天获得干净衣物(调整后OR[AOR]2.5,95%CI 1.4 - 5.0,P < 0.01)。病例组和对照组在静脉注射吸毒使用方面差异最为显著,108例病例中有20例(19%)使用静脉注射吸毒,而104例对照组中有3例(3%)使用(P < 0.01)。最后,108例病例中有35例(32%)有感染史,而104例对照组中只有5例(5%)曾有蜂窝织炎或脓肿(P < 0.01)。回归分析显示软组织感染的显著预测因素是皮肤感染史(AOR 7.0)和不每天清洗衣服(AOR 2.5)。
洗澡习惯方面无显著差异,但病例组和对照组在洗衣习惯上存在显著差异。我们的研究进一步证实静脉注射吸毒是蜂窝织炎的一个风险因素,无法每天获得干净衣服与蜂窝织炎的发生显著相关。不每天洗澡与感染增加无关。