Center for Development and Regional Planning, Federal University of Minas Gerais, Belo Horizonte, Minas Gerais, Brazil.
Takemi Program in International Health, Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health, Boston, Massachusetts, United States of America.
PLoS One. 2018 Aug 10;13(8):e0201723. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0201723. eCollection 2018.
Family Health Strategy, the primary health care program in Brazil, has been scaled up throughout the country, but its expansion has been heterogeneous across municipalities. We investigate if there are unique municipal characteristics that can explain the timing of uptake and the pattern of expansion of the Family Health Strategy from years 1998 to 2012. We categorized municipalities in six groups based on the relative speed of the Family Health Strategy uptake and the pattern of Family Health Strategy coverage expansion. We assembled data for 11 indicators for years 2000 and 2010, for 5,507 municipalities, and assessed differences in indicators across the six groups, which we mapped to examine spatial heterogeneities. Important factors differentiating early and late adopters of the Family Health Strategy were supply of doctors and population density. Sustained coverage expansion was related mainly to population size, marginal benefits of the program and doctors' supply. The uptake was widespread nationwide with no distinct patterns among regions, but highly heterogeneous at the state and municipal level. The Brazilian experience of expanding primary health care offers three lessons in relation to factors influencing diffusion of primary health care. First, the funding mechanism is critical for program implementation, and must be accompanied by ways to support the supply of primary care physicians in low density areas. Second, in more developed and bigger areas the main challenge is lack of incentives to pursue universal coverage, especially due to the availability of private insurance. Third, population size is a crucial element to guarantee coverage sustainability over time.
家庭健康战略是巴西的初级卫生保健项目,已经在全国范围内得到推广,但在各个城市的推广情况存在差异。我们研究了是否存在独特的城市特征,可以解释家庭健康战略从 1998 年到 2012 年的采用时间和扩展模式。我们根据家庭健康战略的采用速度和家庭健康战略覆盖范围的扩展模式,将城市分为六组。我们为 5507 个城市收集了 2000 年和 2010 年 11 项指标的数据,并评估了六个组之间指标的差异,我们将这些差异映射出来以检查空间异质性。区分家庭健康战略早期和晚期采用者的重要因素是医生的供应和人口密度。持续的覆盖范围扩大主要与人口规模、该计划的边际效益和医生的供应有关。该战略在全国范围内得到广泛采用,没有明显的地区差异,但在州和市级层面上存在高度异质性。巴西扩大初级卫生保健的经验提供了三个与影响初级卫生保健扩散的因素有关的经验教训。首先,供资机制对于方案实施至关重要,并且必须辅之以支持在人口密度较低地区提供初级保健医生的方法。其次,在更为发达和更大的地区,主要的挑战是缺乏追求全民覆盖的激励措施,特别是由于私人保险的存在。第三,人口规模是保证覆盖范围随着时间的推移可持续性的关键因素。