Pasina Luca, Recchia Angela, Agosti Pasquale, Nobili Alessandro, Rizzi Barbara
Istituto di Ricerche Farmacologiche Mario Negri IRCCS, MI, Italy.
Fondazione VIDAS, MI, Italy.
Am J Hosp Palliat Care. 2019 Mar;36(3):216-221. doi: 10.1177/1049909118794926. Epub 2018 Aug 16.
The aim of pharmacotherapy in people at the end of life should be symptom control, more than prolonging life. Drugs for disease prevention should therefore be discouraged, but this is not the usual practice. The prevalence of unnecessary preventive drugs at the end of life is not well described, although some studies suggest it is common.
This retrospective longitudinal study describes the prevalence of patients receiving preventive and symptomatic drug treatments at admission (T) and before death (T) in an Italian hospice. All adults admitted to the VIDAS hospice between March 2015 and February 2017 were included in the analysis.
The study sample comprised 589 end-of-life patients with a mean age of 75.3 (12.1) years. The mean number of drugs decreased from admission to the hospice to the time of death (mean [standard deviation]: 9.7 [3.4] and 8.7 [3.0]). All patients were appropriately treated with symptomatic drugs at T and T, while there were significantly fewer patients from T to T with at least 1 preventive medication that could be considered for deprescription at the end of life (511, 86.8% and 286, 48.6%; < .0001).
Hospice admission can be associated with a definite reduction in the use of commonly prescribed preventive medications. However, about half of end-of-life patients can be prescribed avoidable medications. Drugs for peptic ulcer and gastroesophageal reflux disease and antithrombotics were the potentially avoidable preventive medications most frequently prescribed at admission to the hospice and before death.
临终患者药物治疗的目的应是控制症状,而非延长生命。因此,应不鼓励使用预防疾病的药物,但实际情况并非如此。尽管一些研究表明临终时不必要的预防药物很常见,但关于其流行情况的描述并不充分。
这项回顾性纵向研究描述了意大利一家临终关怀机构中患者入院时(T)和死亡前(T)接受预防性和对症药物治疗的情况。分析纳入了2015年3月至2017年2月期间入住VIDAS临终关怀机构的所有成年人。
研究样本包括589名临终患者,平均年龄为75.3(12.1)岁。从入住临终关怀机构到死亡时,药物的平均数量有所减少(平均[标准差]:9.7[3.4]和8.7[3.0])。所有患者在T和T时均接受了适当的对症药物治疗,而从T到T,可考虑在临终时停用至少1种预防性药物的患者明显减少(511例,86.8%和286例,48.6%;P<0.0001)。
入住临终关怀机构可能会导致常用预防药物的使用明显减少。然而,约一半的临终患者可能会被开具可避免的药物。用于消化性溃疡和胃食管反流病的药物以及抗血栓药物是临终关怀机构入院时和死亡前最常开具的潜在可避免的预防药物。