Mueller Melissa A, Pourtaheri Navid, Evans Gregory R D
Department of Plastic and Aesthetic Surgery, University of California Irvine School of Medicine, Orange, California.
Department of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, Case Western Reserve University School of Medicine, Cleveland, Ohio.
J Reconstr Microsurg. 2019 Mar;35(3):176-181. doi: 10.1055/s-0038-1668160. Epub 2018 Aug 18.
Given emerging focus on competency-based surgical training and work-hour limitations, surgical skills laboratories play an increasingly important role in resident education. This study was designed to investigate educational opportunities in microsurgery across integrated residency programs.
Senior residents (PGY 4-6) at integrated plastic surgery programs were surveyed during the 2016 to 2017 academic year to determine each program's access to: training microscopes and anastomosis models, video-based skills assessment, pre-requisite skills exams, flap courses, or a formal microsurgical training curriculum. Programs were stratified based on large size (>18 residents) and presence of microsurgery fellows. Chi-squared analysis was performed with < 0.05 to assess statistical significance.
Survey responses were collected from 32 of 60 eligible programs (53% response rate). Sixty-nine percent provide access to one to two training microscopes, 25% provide three or more, and 6% provide none. Sixty-nine percent of programs train anastomosis with nonliving prosthetics, 66% with living biologics, and 50% with nonliving biologics. Large program size or having microsurgical fellows was not associated with increased access to training microscopes or specific anastomosis models. Programs without microsurgery fellows reported more often that a formal microsurgery curriculum would be helpful (90 vs. 58% of programs with fellows, = 0.0003). Respondents who indicated that creating a formal curriculum would not be helpful elaborated that their program already has a formal curriculum or a high volume of microsurgery cases.
This study demonstrates the current variation in microsurgery training at integrated plastic surgery residency programs. A formal microsurgical training curriculum is commonly viewed as being helpful, particularly at programs without microsurgery fellows.
鉴于对基于胜任力的外科培训和工作时间限制的关注日益增加,手术技能实验室在住院医师教育中发挥着越来越重要的作用。本研究旨在调查综合住院医师培训项目中显微外科的教育机会。
在2016至2017学年对综合整形外科项目的高级住院医师(PGY 4 - 6)进行了调查,以确定每个项目是否能够使用:训练显微镜和吻合模型、基于视频的技能评估、先修技能考试、皮瓣课程或正式的显微外科培训课程。根据规模大小(>18名住院医师)和是否有显微外科专科住院医师对项目进行分层。采用卡方分析,P < 0.05评估统计学意义。
从60个符合条件的项目中的32个收集了调查回复(回复率为53%)。69%的项目提供一到两台训练显微镜,25%的项目提供三台或更多,6%的项目没有提供。69%的项目使用非生物假体训练吻合,66%使用生物活体,50%使用非生物生物材料。项目规模大或有显微外科专科住院医师与获得训练显微镜或特定吻合模型的机会增加无关。没有显微外科专科住院医师的项目更常报告说正式的显微外科课程会有帮助(90%对有专科住院医师项目的58%,P = 0.0003)。表示制定正式课程没有帮助的受访者详细说明他们的项目已经有正式课程或有大量显微外科病例。
本研究表明综合整形外科住院医师培训项目中显微外科培训目前存在差异。正式的显微外科培训课程通常被认为是有帮助的,特别是在没有显微外科专科住院医师的项目中。