Coutin Alexandre, Wright Sarah, Li Christine, Fung Raymond
Faculty of Medicine, University of Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Department of Medical Education, University of Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Can Med Educ J. 2018 Jul 27;9(3):e41-e55. eCollection 2018 Jul.
The transgender (trans) population faces multiple barriers in accessing health care, with knowledge deficits of health care providers contributing substantially. Trans patients report having to teach health care professionals about their own health needs. We compared perceptions of trans-care education and training across family medicine, psychiatry, endocrinology, and urology residency training programs at the University of Toronto.
We surveyed residents to assess their perceptions of and attitudes towards trans-care, exposure to trans patients, knowledge of trans-specific clinical care, and the state of trans-care education within their training. We used Likert scale data to identify patterns across residency programs. We collected open-ended responses to further explain quantitative findings where appropriate.
Of 556 residents approached, 319 participated (response rate = 57.4%). Nearly all endocrinology and psychiatry residents agreed that trans-care falls within their scope of practice, while only 71% and 50% of family medicine and urology residents did, respectively. Though participants were at different stages of their postgraduate training when surveyed, only 17% of all participants predicted they would feel competent to provide specialty-specific trans-care by the end of their residency and only 12% felt that their training was adequate to care for this population.
Though the study revealed a willingness to serve this population, there was a lack of clinical exposure and trans-related teaching within postgraduate curricula resulting in feelings of unpreparedness to meet the health care needs of this underserved population.
跨性别者在获得医疗保健方面面临多重障碍,医疗保健提供者的知识欠缺是一个重要因素。跨性别患者表示,他们不得不向医疗保健专业人员传授自身的健康需求。我们比较了多伦多大学家庭医学、精神病学、内分泌学和泌尿外科学住院医师培训项目对跨性别医疗教育与培训的看法。
我们对住院医师进行了调查,以评估他们对跨性别医疗的看法和态度、接触跨性别患者的情况、跨性别特定临床护理的知识以及培训中跨性别医疗教育的状况。我们使用李克特量表数据来确定各住院医师培训项目的模式。我们收集了开放式回答,以便在适当情况下进一步解释定量研究结果。
在接触的556名住院医师中,319人参与了调查(回复率 = 57.4%)。几乎所有内分泌学和精神病学住院医师都认为跨性别医疗属于他们的执业范围,而家庭医学和泌尿外科学住院医师中分别只有71%和50%这样认为。尽管在调查时参与者处于研究生培训的不同阶段,但所有参与者中只有17%预计在住院医师培训结束时他们会觉得自己有能力提供特定专科的跨性别医疗服务,只有12%的人觉得他们的培训足以照顾这一人群。
尽管研究显示有服务这一人群的意愿,但研究生课程中缺乏临床接触和与跨性别相关的教学,导致他们感觉没有准备好满足这一服务不足人群的医疗保健需求。