School of Public Health and Health Professions, University at Buffalo, Buffalo, New York.
Center for Innovation in Global Health, Stanford University, Stanford, California.
Am J Trop Med Hyg. 2018 Oct;99(4):899-904. doi: 10.4269/ajtmh.17-0583.
Available measures of handwashing are prone to bias. We tested the feasibility and reliability of weighing soap at repeated visits and subtracting the measured weight from the prior weight to assess daily per capita soap consumption in a low-income community in Dhaka, Bangladesh. Fieldworkers approached 220 households twice weekly over 2 months. They interviewed participants, weighed soap, and assessed hand cleanliness and the presence of a handwashing station. Respondents used bar soap (91% [201]) and laundry detergent cakes (39% [85]) for handwashing as well as for bathing and laundry. Ninety-eight percent of households had bar soap present on at least one visit, although only 50% had bar soap at every visit during the 2-month period. Fieldworkers observed a soap fragment on the wall near the latrine in 27% (470) of visits. Households consumed a mean 1.5 g of bar soap and 3.2 g detergent cake per person per day. Daily per capita soap consumption was similar in households visited by fieldworkers after different intervals (2, 3, 4, or 5 days). Soap consumption was not associated with household wealth, education of the household head, the presence of a handwashing station, the presence of water or soap at a handwashing station, or palm inspections of the mother or child. Soap weight measurements were an objective, reliable measure of soap consumption that provided different information from other handwashing indicators. The frequent use of a soap product for purposes other than handwashing complicates using soap consumption as a handwashing measure.
现有的洗手衡量措施容易产生偏差。我们测试了在重复访问时称重肥皂并从先前的重量中减去测量重量来评估孟加拉国达卡一个低收入社区中每个人每天的肥皂消耗量的可行性和可靠性。工作人员每两周两次接触 220 户家庭。他们采访了参与者,称重肥皂,并评估了手部清洁度和洗手站的存在情况。受访者既用肥皂(91%[201])又用洗衣皂(39%[85])洗手,也用于洗澡和洗衣。98%的家庭至少有一次肥皂,尽管在两个月期间,只有 50%的家庭每次访问都有肥皂。工作人员在 27%(470)次访问中观察到厕所附近墙上有一块肥皂碎片。家庭平均每人每天消耗 1.5 克肥皂和 3.2 克洗衣皂。工人访问过的家庭之间,无论间隔时间为 2、3、4 或 5 天,人均肥皂消耗量相似。肥皂消耗量与家庭财富、家庭主要成员的教育程度、洗手站的存在、洗手站是否有水和肥皂、母亲或儿童手掌检查均无关。肥皂重量测量是一种客观、可靠的肥皂消耗量衡量标准,与其他洗手指标提供的信息不同。经常将一种肥皂产品用于洗手以外的目的,这使得将肥皂消耗量作为洗手衡量标准变得复杂。